Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

paul’s journal

Throwing your money "at the windows"

· · 🌡️ 23°F

This is just a continuation of @paul #47049 as I am still so angry about this issue.

@james, you are right, we need to get some politicians behind this. Even just starting with the city of buffalo, there must be so much in possible savings. The problem is getting information about what they currently are using. We need a tech person on the inside who cares. I think tax payers are not outraged because they do not understand the issue, all it would take is some awareness.

The City of Buffalo represents a perfect candidate for free and open source change because:

1. It is so poor and our taxes are so high.
2. It is a pure government entitity unlike Roswell where some of the money comes from grants.
3. Its not that big compared to New York State.
4. We have access to policticans who could make it an issue.

Building Future Workers
A interesting way to promote this would be to pick an OS for the city customize the build to its needs. Then release the live CDs on the cities website so that citizens could download the OS for their own computers. It would help people who can't afford to buy windows products and it would also effectively train new city workers in using the software. If you use open office, firefox, etc at home then you won't have a problem using it at work. With all the money that would be saved, you could afford to have more programers customizing Free and Open Source software for the government needs, so they could get what they really want and need.

The Nay-sayser
The worst part of transitioning anything are the government employees who say I am only trained in microsoft tech. Well, you know what, getting a government job should not be the only pre-requisite to keeping a state job - as it seems to be. Especially, in technology. Technology changes and people need to adapt to new technology and more importantly - new budgets. Their lack of willing to learn and train in cost savings alternitves should equate losing their jobs to people who are committed to cost saving technologies.

Its not that hard to learn new technology. If you are a computer server tech, you could definately learn linux - if not capable of that you are in the wrong field.

If you are an administrative assistant, you can learn to type reports on open office software. It kills me to think how much money is thrown out the window or as I said in the last post "thrown at the windows"

💬 7 comments

  1. jenks ·

    I haven't used openoffice much, but it seems more than adequate... I installed it on parallels and bootcamp b/c I didn't want to buy another stupid $$$ copy of Office that I will almost never use, but need just in case I have to open a .doc file or whatever.

    I sent the tech support people at BGH a while ago an email saying how ridiculous it is that they still use IE6. of course they didn't respond and nothing came of it.

    You don't even need to learn new things to upgrade from IE6 to 7. And it's FREE. Frankly I think everyone should use safari/firefox, but if they insist on stupid IE, at least get 7. Apple's mobileme stuff won't even RUN on 6.
  2. paul ·

    Its a complicated issue. Its just just the tech people being dumb as it might seem. The problem are the vendors. They built software that works on IE6, then they made all their money and don't care about upgrading or helping. Its a viscious cycle. That is why I think the government should be required to only use open source software, so that at least its own tech team could the opportunity to change stuff.

    Stuff can be open source and the companies can make money on support, which is fine. Its not like every vendor product would be replace by software managed entirely by internal staff.

    I guess in it a way it is the tech support staff's fault because the buy the sofwtare without checking. A good example would be our new web based time tracking system purchased by HRI Albany that only works in IE. We just bought it in 2008. Hwo can there even be web software in 2008 that is not standards compliant enough to work in any modern browser.
  3. tinypliny ·

    Heh.. OpenOffice is exactly the same as MS Office but with added PDF output features and several customizable options. There is hardly anything to "learn".
  4. gardenmama ·

    I am so out of the technology loop - I think I need to explore. My home computer is really old, and at work, though the district provides extensive professional development for teachers, they provide very little (ok, almost none) p.d. for support staff. We all use MS Office products at work and I came in (8 yrs. ago) knowing how to do a lot more with the software than many of my co-worker who had been there for many years. I frequently find myself teaching my co-workers about capabilities of the software and how to use it. Part of the problem for us is there is a huge disparity in people's knowledge of the software and you can't "make" them learn it. Some people will actually say "I don't know how to do that, and I don't want to learn" and the union would protect them because our job descriptions do not really include anything about technology skills (other than must be able to accurately type at 35 words per min. - hell, you can do that with the hunt and peck method). Also, when the district used to offer some support staff training, I wanted to take a 3-course series (one day each) on the MS Office database program (which would have benefitted our office) but my supervisor said she would only be willing to let me go for one day, but that 3 was too much. Well, I ended up not going to any because I knew that just the one would be sufficient to suite my needs.
  5. zobar ·

    You'd obviously save a buttload on software licensing fees. You'd save on ongoing server costs too because while the Linux server platform is occasionally arcane, it's generally quite solid and efficient, whereas the Windows server platform is extremely frustrating and seems to be less stable in general.

    I think the desktops would require less maintenance but slightly more support. You'd need to increase help staff during the transition of course, but I don't think you'd ever completely get over the unfamiliarity thing.

    The real big question is about vertical-market applications that you may have to replace and phase out. My impression is that the majority of ready-to-use municipal-government software is either Windows-based or really old like AS/400. If you can't bring in a Linux replacement app, you need to consult or hire your own developers, which will cost more than the status quo.

    - Z
  6. heidi ·

    I usually work with small scale organizations - 1 to 5 computer users with no IT staff. I encourage people to use OpenOffice but they get frustrated if it doesn't work "right" the first time, and compatibility can still be problematic. Sometimes I just demand that they use Firefox (gently but still a demand) because of the safety issues. @zobar's right about municipal software being old - there are still DOS water/sewer/garbage programs being supported. What a nightmare.

    But as you scale up from the little shops, it's hard to tell where the line is where your IT staff is good & strong enough to handle switching to opensource, and where your staff will be okay with switching (balancing resistance & time/skill, I guess).
  7. drew ·

    I think it would be really cool if Buffalo became the US's first (as far as I know) "open source city." If we did it big and did it right. it could attract some people and maybe even jump start our tech economy. People can program from anywhere, and Buffalo is a pretty cheap/awesome place to live!

💬 Write a comment