Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

paul’s journal

Workfare instead of welfare?

· · 🌡️ 62°F

A continuation of @paul #48807 What about a workfare program? What if instead of paying people to stay home, we give them state job doing all the things that need being done.

Obviously, I am only talking about people who are physically capable. If childcare is an issue than they could pick child care providers out of the group and have them watch children while the parents took turns working.

I mean our society has so much stuff that need to be done, and a lot of people that "desperately want jobs but can't find them." We pay them either way, why not let society (the people themselves included) reap some benefit from the tax money spent.

Then their salaries can just show up with all the other state workers? Is that ok?

There were plenty of examples of this during the depression with public works projects.

💬 10 comments

  1. james ·

    But that, more or less, happens a lot already.

    Last year I qualified for HEAP, food stamps, and medicare. I didn't have any of those and I worked almost all of last year except December. It wasn't for the government, but I worked like a lot of people who receive assistance do.

    I think it would be important in this discussion if we had some actual facts and figures on welfare. How many people receive it, how many work, how long people are on it, etc. Otherwise this is just speculative.
  2. paul ·

    Ya, that part is true? Where are those numbers? That is kind of what I am asking for?
  3. jim ·

    If you are capable of working, and don't have dependents, you can't stay on welfare for very long already.

    "About 44 percent of TANF households are not subject to federal or state time limits because they are “child-only cases” â€" typically, children living with a relative or families in which the parent is not eligible for benefits."

    So, almost half the list would be names of children. That's not very awesome.
  4. james ·

    This is from a 1994 report from the House Ways and Means Committee. Though, it would be very interesting to see more up to date information.

    Race
    --------------
    White 38.8%
    Black 37.2
    Hispanic 17.8
    Asian 2.8
    Other 3.4

    Time on AFDC
    ---------------------------
    Less than 7 months 19.0%
    7 to 12 months 15.2
    One to two years 19.3
    Two to five years 26.9
    Over five years 19.6

    Number of children
    -------------------
    One 43.2%
    Two 30.7
    Three 15.8
    Four or more 10.3

    Age of Mother
    ------------------
    Teenager 7.6%
    20 - 29 47.9
    30 - 39 32.7
    40 or older 11.8

    Status of Father 1973 1992
    -------------------------------------
    Divorced or separated 46.5% 28.6
    Deceased 5.0 1.6
    Unemployed or Disabled 14.3 9.0
    Not married to mother 31.5 55.3
    Other or Unknown 2.7 5.5
  5. paul ·

    James: I am curious about that plus total payouts.
    Jim: I think plenty of people have additional dependents to stay on it. that is why I suggested the childcare part.
  6. deeglam ·

    fabulous idea.
  7. theecarey ·

    Interesting, @jim. I forgot that many of the recipients are children only.
    I wouldn't be opposed to giving them "government chores", though.
    On that note @paul,as part of the welfare process, if an individual is physically capable of working,then they have to look for work and/or be expected to work an assigned amount of hours per month as part of being in the system, at a location predetermined for them. It could be shoveling public sidewalks, picking up garbage, clerical duties, farming, etc. So there is a workfare program in place. At first consideration, I do like your idea about childcare- choosing some qualified individuals from the mix to look over the others children (and that may already be in place?)
    The amount "paid" to those in the workfare program is the absolute minimum. There are two things I am unsure on:
    1. what the rate of pay actually is. It used to be much less than "minimum wage", with the idea that the individual would be better off finding independent employment that would likely pay much better. That "pay rate" may have changed to provide a minimum monetary expectation now. Anyone have data? and,
    2. There has/had been much debate as to whether these people are considered "employees" of anyone, and if they have employee rights etc. Again, I haven't checked recent data to what, if anything has changed over the years. If they are still not classified as "employees" then their "wages" as per criteria would not be published based on this.

    On a related note, to what degree would/does having low wage "workfare participants" benefit the state (and some private companies) more than if they hired out right workers? We may have people abusing the system, but that would also include the state and businesses that hire them- an initiative to keep people in the system, perhaps? Just thoughts..
  8. ajay ·

    A few years ago, NYC decided that if you're physically capable of working and on welfare, then the City would require you to work cleaning up the streets, etc. IIRC, a lot of the folks affected protested. The protesters were all hefty guys who could have done the job easily; but they were protesting the fact that the jobs were "beneath" them....

    I think if someone's on welfare and they're not (a) in school, bettering their sills, or (b) doing job interviews, then they should be required to do mundane tasks like cleaning up grafitti, sidewalks, abandoned houses, etc. Alternately: give preference to contractors who will take welfare people off the rolls.
  9. heidi ·

    Paul -

    To give you some numbers, I need to know what kind of "welfare" you're objecting to/curious about... there multiple social programs that someone considers to be "welfare":

    TANF: Temporary Assistance to Needy Families. This is the program that replaced AFDC (Aid to Families with Dependent Children) back in 1996 with Clinton's Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act, which is the program that @james' comment describes. As both names suggest, they're focused on kids and their parent(s). The exact program regulations and $ benefits vary by state, but it's the main program that is called "welfare"
    :::link:::

    Social Security (federal welfare for old people and kids who have lost a parent)
    Social Security Disability (federal welfare for people w/disabilities, including HIV/AIDS)
    Supplemental Security Income
    Medicaid (state-administered federal health care for poor people)
    Medicare (federal health care for seniors & disabled)
    SCHIP (state-administered federal health care for poorer kids)
    HEAP (heating/cooling assistance for poor people)
    Food stamps
    WIC (women, infants & children food assistance)
    Title XX (funding for childcare for working parents)
    Unemployment Compensation
    Workers Compensation (workplace injury care)
    Earned Income Tax Credit (returns earned income tax dollars to poor people)

    Here's the NYS list of assistance programs:
    :::link:::

    In PA, the equivalent of the Safety Net Assistance program is "general assistance" and the benefit was approx. $197 per month. I'm pretty sure the recycling collectors along Allen St. make more than that.

    I'd also like to contrast TANF expenditures, which in the Obama FY2010 budget would be approximately $19.3 billion with "corporate welfare": "According to the Cato Institute, the U.S. federal government spent $92 billion on corporate welfare during fiscal year 2006. Recipients included Boeing, Xerox, IBM, Motorola, Dow Chemical, and General Electric.[5]" (I don't particularly trust Cato, but it's a nice line for my purposes at the moment.)

    FY2010 US Dept. of Health & Human Services budget
    :::link:::
    I couldn't find actual FY2008 TANF expenditures, but Bush's budget was approximately $15 billion - and let's not discuss all the "marriage promotion" activities that included.
  10. metalpeter ·

    What @theecarey says it correct. I think workfare is through the county. Maybe it could go through the state also. I remember hearing that one of the big problems with workfare was that a lot of the Jobs people could do they didn't have the education for. If you think about it that makes sense. See if they had the education then they could get a job and not abuse the system.

💬 Write a comment