Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

enknot’s journal

Dom's Response

· · 🌡️ 60°F

Dom responded, and his response was awesome check this out!

Very cool science show. They seem like they know what they are talking about from the little bit I listened too. These new HIV drugs aren't really vaccines exactly, but it sounds like they have great potential.

The question of "is it good for humans later" is pointless as far as I am concerned. Nature is a cruel master. Civilizations have developed to help cope with nature. We build shelters to protect us. We build social structures to help us get food and water. We build medical systems to help keep us healthy. We can do these things because we have evolved these capabilities. To not use those abilities would be stymie - ing evolution.

Mitchondria came from a symbiotic relationship between bacteria and eukaryotic single cell organisms. This infection happened before we evolved the ability to fight infections...

Suppose we did not treat HIV. Like the story says, there are some people who have a specific mutation in the CCR5 receptor that won't allow HIV infection. If everyone gets exposed to HIV, only these people and others who have other sorts of protective differences ("mutations") will survive. Now, a couple hundred years later, humanity is more "fit" because evolution ran its course concerning this one thing - HIV infection.

Good in theory, but will not happen exactly BECAUSE of evolution. Bald eagles almost became extinct because of a chemical that came into their environment (it doesn't matter that we were responsible for this point) which made their egg shells more fragile. The eggs could not support the weight of the parents that sit on them. so the eggs would collapse and the parent crushed the young. Eagles are not smart enough to realize that maybe they shouldn't sit on their eggs any longer. They are not able to build nice warm, cozy incubators for their eggs. In fact, if we had not removed the chemical from their environment in the 70's (DDT, I think) they would very likely be extinct right now.

Humans, on the other hand, have evolved such abilities. We are not wild animals and we could not survive for long without the social structures we have put in place. Why should it be OK to deny the use of a drug like this to help against a viral infection, but not OK to no longer allow trucks to deliver food from rural farm areas to cities. How would all those people in NYC eat?

There is another argument: Let's say there are some mutant eagles that build super strong eggs, so they don't crush their young. All the non-mutant eagles die off after a few generations, so now the species has evolved to have only these mutant eagles with super strong eggs are left. The chemical in the environment is not threat to these remaining eagles. Only 2% of the total original eagle population had this mutation. Luckily, the eagle population was large enough and varied enough for this mutation to be a possibility. But now, the genetic fitness of eagles is dramatically less. The population has lost 98% of its variation. What happens if another challenge comes along that these eagles can't handle? The genetic variation for many, many generations of these eagles will be so small that is it highly unlikely they would be able to survive another challenge like, let's say, an avian HIV. Maybe all of the eagles that had a mutation in CCR5 that could have saved them from avian HIV. Unfortunately, none of them had the super strong egg mutation so they all crushed their young and died off.

The exact same concepts would be applied to the human HIV story. If we let it run its course, and part of the population survived and that population is now somehow better able to withstand viral attacks because of this evolution, the genetic fitness of humanity would be much worse off.

So, my point is that evolution gave us the ability to protect ourselves and to not use those abilities is to ignore evolution. You could extend my theory to the n'th degree and say that eventually, nothing will be able to kill us. Where do you draw the line between benefiting from the abilities you have evolved, and actually interfering so much with evolution that you destroy the concept altogether? In a way, this is already happening. There are people with genetic mutations that would normally kill them before they were old enough to breed. Medical interventions now allow them to live long enough to breed. They do. Now there are more people with these mutations that would have been winnowed out without medical intervention.

I am not sure I have the answer for "where do you draw the line?". I've given this very little thought, but I think you draw the line at changing the genetic material of the gametes (sperm and egg). I think this would be wrong. But maybe it is not so simple as that. If you could take two people with cystic fibrosis, and fix the single mutation that causes the disease, I would say we should do that. These people could live normal lives with normal lung function. The gene would only need to be fixed in specific cells in the airways. In fact, some of the very 1st gene therapy experiments were to do exactly this. But what about when those two people get married and decide they want kids? Should we fix the bad gene in their sperm and eggs so that their kids come out normal?? I don't think so, because now you have pushed the line....how far do you push it? People with sickle cell anemia, which could theoretically be fixed in such a way, are resistant to malaria. What if cystic fibrosis people have some benefit we don't recognize yet?

Anyway.....I have to get back to work.

No, I don't know anyone studying bone density.

💬 3 comments

  1. tinypliny ·

    And I can bet that in a few years (with the huge Stem cell research board :::link:::), the line that Dom is talking about will no longer exist. I know that manipulation of germ cells seems unethical now, but I can easily believe that people might become more receptive to it when they realize that more lives could be saved.

    However much one talks about evolution, I think the basic tendency for all living species on this planet is to survive. If survival involves the use of advanced intelligence, it is definitely one of the evolutionary benefits that the struggling species should (and will) use - no matter how unethical it may seem. You could say that evolution programs us not to care. Maybe the consequences of our "intelligent" actions are also part of the evolutionary design.
  2. metalpeter ·

    Very Interesting post. One thing that I wonder about though is, would curing HIV really be a good thing or a bad thing medicly. The reason I say this is that I have heard that some doctors don't give out antibotics like they used to. The reason being is what happened was that over time what they where fighting adapted and got stronger and made the medicines less effective so doctors don't want to cause something so strong that medicine won't be able to fight it. If you look at how diases have changed over time it makes sense. The black plague killed lots of people. Then there where things like TB and the newest one is AIDS/HIV . Well what if fighting HIV causes something stronger to form. The thing I find weird about HIV is what makes it so deadly is that it kills you slowly. If you got HIV and died 2 days later you wouldn't be able to spread it to anyone else. But with HIV you can spreed it to hundreds if you are the popular type, before you even know. What if the new HIV Virus learns how to survive in temps that are colder then body temp or even worse how to stay alive in the in the air for a few minutes that sure would make things a lot worse. I'm not expert just putting down a few thoughts.
  3. scott ·

    On a side note: DDT may have been bad for bald eagle eggs, but it's (by far) the most effective weapon against malaria... which happens to kill more people than aids ever will!

    peep this awesome article from Nat. Geographic...
    :::link:::

    Oh, the circle of life....

💬 Write a comment