Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

heidi’s journal

Promissory Estoppel

·

I'm reading the info on distinctions between Pennsylvania contract law and common law or Uniform Commercial Code Art. 2 and it includes promissory estoppel, which @kookcity2000 thinks is interesting.

Promissory estoppel allows a promisee to enforce a promise against a promisor even when there's no consideration. Consideration is a legal detriment that binds one to a contract. It's usually money for service or product but it could be product for service or something else.

Example: @lilho promises @paul that she will give him a year's worth of tortoise food if he stops going out dancing for a month. @paul thinks this is a good bargain and stops growing dandelions and strawberries for Basra and T2. At the end of the month, @paul hasn't been dancing but @lilho laughs and says she wasn't serious. Now Basra and T2 are hungry. Can @paul sue @lilho for tortoise food?

Yes! Why?
- Was a contract formed? @lilho made an offer, @paul accepted, so yes.
- Was there consideration? @lilho isn't getting anything for her promise, so no (@paul not dancing for a month doesn't affect @lilho's life although that's what she asked for).
- So why can @paul sue? Promissory estoppel: Because he relied on @lilho's promise by tearing out the dandelion and strawberry garden and an injustice will occur if @lilho's promise is not enforced - Basra & T2 would go hungry. Was it reasonably foreseeable (or even just reasonable) that @paul would rely on the promise? Yes, because @paul thinks growing tortoise food is a pain.

Share 271 words · edited Jan 31, 2012

💬 4 comments

  1. metalpeter ·

    That is pretty interesting.... My legal question is.. Is that the same as what is called and Oral or Verbal Contract?
  2. heidi ·

    Oral contracts can be enforceable under certain circumstances. If the value of the contract is over $500 or if it is for one of the following items, it must be in writing: Marriage (like a prenuptual agreement), suretyship, land, contracts than can't be performed within one year, and contracts covered by the Uniform Commercial Code. I was assuming the cost of one year of tortoise food is less than $500.
  3. metalpeter ·

    ah so then they are different ok thanks.... Not that I need any legal advice I was just wondering....
  4. kookcity2000 ·

    I do, I love that shit. I would probably love anything distilled to its most interesting points and was still accessible from my couch though.

💬 Write a comment