Organic vs Cheap
I definitely see the value in buying organic, local, and/or fair trade food when possible. I am well aware of the impact pesticides have on the environment and how unsustainable most of our food supply is without tons of petrochemicals. I've heard about the potential health risks of residual pesticides. But I've never been able to get myself to spend for organic.
I've been shopping at Aldi for close to 5 years now. Of all the discount stores, I think they're the cleanest and best run (that ruthless German efficiency!). I don't know where they source any of their mostly non-organic produce and food, but I know that their workers are paid at least $12/hr and managers $20, plus benefits. I could always get by shopping on a $30/week grocery budget, where Giant Eagle in Cleveland would have cost me closer to $60. Same thing for Wegmans and the coop costing much more. I would love to get my food from there but I sink my budget into my loans.
Is it selfish of me to be cheap and buy crazy unknown Aldi food when now I can technically afford more? I definitely have noticed a quality difference between what I've been buying vs what Paul and Terry get at the coop and Wegmans. I said it's worse to be feeding the student loan monster with interest over industrial ag, but that's me justifying it after the fact.
Maybe I can become a couponer like @mike or my mom and shop at Wegmans. Or skip the local aspect and keeping going for cheap organic way out at Trader Joe's. Either way it's good to be challenged.
I do not agree with Paul that:
a) the coop is always high quality
b) organic is any better for health
c) paying more means you get more "quality"
d) quality is not available at reasonable prices
e) organic is sustainable in the long run
f) organic is good for a population struggling with affordable and basic healthful food choices
g) local is always the way to go.
We live in a global economy and it is borderline ridiculous to be stuck in the buy-local buy-organic rut at all times without hard evidence-supported benefits. Science is far from being black and white about why organic is any better. Take a look: :::link:::
And I am sure @paul will agree when I point out that he is a snob{*}. Not all of us can afford to turn up our noses at Pricerite when the primary objective is to maintain a good health status and meet nutritional requirements while being on a near-poverty line or low income salary.
It is hard to cater to some activist notion of selling our soul and budgets for unperceivable benefits to our health or to the (for the most part) unregulated "organic" industry when you are wondering how best to afford the maximum proportion of fresh produce that definitely will stop you from sliding into the spiral of chronic diseases - most of which are poor diet related.
{*}He said so himself. :-)
More debate from the past: :::link:::
{Look at the comments section for massive debate!} :::link:::
---
Paul being snobbish :::link::: :::link::: :::link:::