Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

james’s journal

Captan Jack's

· 🌡️ 75°F

So,

a new take out place opened on Elmwood right near the ghetto liquor store and We Never Close. Captain Jack's Fish and Chips.
First, I am super excited they did all that work on those two store fronts. One now has this restaurant, the other will have the Elmwood Village Association in it. Both are awesome neighbors.
Second, I love fish and I am bit disappointed by my fish options around here. Oh, Friday fish try? Thanks. Hey, wanna watch 2girls1cup the Musical? It is about that appetizing.
On their menu they have:
Sea Dogs
Fish tacos
Lunker
Crabcakes
Seafood Ravioli
and other treats including non-fishies.

I treated myself to a sea dog and a fish taco.

The sea dog is basically a foot long fried fish stick on a hot dog bun with tarter sauce, which was yellow, odd. It was good for what it was and totally worth the $3.99

The fish taco was.... the same thing. A jumbo fish stick with mango salsa, tarter sauce, and in a tortilla.... making it a burrito and not a taco, god damn it.

Both were meh. The service needed work, but everyone was friendly and apologetic when they made a mistake. They just opened so that is bound to get better. But the food... I need something more than just a fancy-pants way of dolling up a fish stick.

I will try some of their other offerings, but if I see another fish stick I am calling it quits.

💬 4 comments

  1. uncutsaniflush ·

    I would suspect that the "yellow" in the tartar sauce is probably mustard based on my personal experience. Over the years, I've experienced a number of "home-made" tartar sauces that use hot dog mustard.
  2. james ·

    It sure as heck wasn't saffron. That was my guess as well. It goes with the hot dog theme as well.
  3. paul ·

    I was hoping you would love it.
  4. james ·

    Me too. I will try it again soon, but I wont get either of those items again unless I am broke and drunk.

💬 Write a comment