Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

james’s journal

Pope Excommunicates Rape Victim's Family

· 🌡️ 27°F

I try not to talk about how much I utterly detest the Catholic Church (the Church, not Catholics). I feel it puts Catholics on the defensive, and I don't want anybody defending the indefensible. But crap rabbit, this shit just pissed me off all day.

In Brazil, a nine year old girl was raped by her step-father and conceived twins. Abortion is illegal in Brazil, except under certain circumstances. The girl weighed only 80 lbs, and would have probably died had she carried both babies to a team of doctors.

So here we have
1) Rape
2) Pedophilia
3) The life of the mother
4) Incest (sorta)

So, with the blessing of the state an abortion is performed and the life of the girl is saved.

And in steps the Vatican. They excommunicated the doctors for performing the abortion and the mother for consenting to it. "God's law is above any human law" the Vatican spokesbishop said.

This infuriates me for a number of reasons.

First, the life of unborn children is more important than the life of the mother. Rome is saying they would prefer the nine year old would die. All life is precious, the Church argues. But what they mean to say is unborn life is precious, the living isn't.

Second, the church has a right to their own ideology. If they are against abortion, I am fine with that. But the vitriol they have for abortion is unmatched. The mother and doctors were excommunicated. The rapist/pedophile father is, in contrast, is still in full communion with the church. They give a choice to the doctors and mother, either save this girls life or save your eternal soul. The rapist/pedophile is free to rape away until St. Peter welcomes him with open arms into heaven. Do rapist/pedophiles get to spend eternity with their step children in heaven?

The Church has held it up over the last century as the supreme moral authority on earth. More so as it lost its role as supreme political authority in Europe. The church will put the full force of its moral power onto a lifesaving act but will make high positions of authority who deny the overwhelming weight of evidence for the holocaust. Politics is always before morality. Morality is a tool to political ends.

When other denominations are having debates relative to the 21st century, it is upsetting, but not surprising, to see the church having the same debate it had in the 19th century.

If these are the actions used to define you are a moral authority, you do not deserve a seat among those discussing morality.

💬 5 comments

  1. theli ·

    Pretty horrid.
  2. jason ·

    This is the institution that used "canon" to protect boy-rapers, so this comes as little surprise to me.
  3. james ·

    I need to learn how to read. For a few seconds I was trying to think when the church was trying to protect boy-rappers like KrisKross
  4. metalpeter ·

    First of all I agree kinda with what you are saying. First of all the raper should also be excommunicated. I think to excommunicate someone because they are raped and have an abortion is crazy and to do the same thing to the doctors, is really bad. But that being said to "The Church" Abortion is a sin. The circumstances don't change that. The fact that she was raped doesn't change that. A sin is a sin and because you had Just Cause doesn't not make it a Sin. From there point of view in really makes a lot of sense. I don't agree with there point of view myself. But see a lot of the church isn't about Morality, yes I said that it is about following the laws of god. Even though you didn't chose it when you are raped you had sex out side of marriage. Birth Control is a Sin so lets say she was on the pill (not that she would be at 9) and she didn't get pregnant then that would be a sin. I have also heard some arguments like this for breaking laws because based on god they are unjust laws. In terms of this belief system if you repent and do what you have to do, then yes you get into heaven. I still don't get why nothing happened to the guy. I wonder if there is more to this story then what is being reported. How often does a 9 year old have a kid, on top of that by being raped. I know it is Brazil but still. I'm not saying I agree with the church on this because I don't, I just think we don't have all the facts.
  5. tinypliny ·

    I say good riddance. Soon all that will be left of them will be a bunch of pedophiles and rapists.

💬 Write a comment