They Just Don't Get Buffalo
There was a piece in the Friday Times about Buffalo's architectural history and our future. I just don't think the authors understand a damn about our city.
1) There are some very significant large structures, yes. Darwin Martin, Richardson complex, all great. But the gems of Buffalo are in the homes where Plebes like us live in mansions. The omni-presence of beauty was missing and the author did not get it.
2) Richmond Avenue is not "one of Olmsted's grand decaying parkways". If there have been any successes in Buffalo it has been on Richmond. I can't think of a home that taints the whole avenue with the air of decay.
3) The author thinks that the Mayor's plan to knock down 5,000 is a failure of the preservationist movement. However, they do not mention Buffalo Re-Use will get to sack these homes for architectural goodies like stained glass, copper pipes, etc. Nor does the author mention that 20% of the homes in the city are vacant and will always be vacant. There are no plans in the works for a revitalized economy that will fill those homes. There are some plans to revitalize the neighborhoods in which they are situated. But we just do not have the resources to restore 18,000 homes and we do not have the people to put in them.
blah!
1) There are some very significant large structures, yes. Darwin Martin, Richardson complex, all great. But the gems of Buffalo are in the homes where Plebes like us live in mansions. The omni-presence of beauty was missing and the author did not get it.
2) Richmond Avenue is not "one of Olmsted's grand decaying parkways". If there have been any successes in Buffalo it has been on Richmond. I can't think of a home that taints the whole avenue with the air of decay.
3) The author thinks that the Mayor's plan to knock down 5,000 is a failure of the preservationist movement. However, they do not mention Buffalo Re-Use will get to sack these homes for architectural goodies like stained glass, copper pipes, etc. Nor does the author mention that 20% of the homes in the city are vacant and will always be vacant. There are no plans in the works for a revitalized economy that will fill those homes. There are some plans to revitalize the neighborhoods in which they are situated. But we just do not have the resources to restore 18,000 homes and we do not have the people to put in them.
blah!
In terms of Point 3 you make. The guy doesn't tackle that but if he did it would be a 7 page article. Well no you would have to get into Politics and talk about PUSH and How people put pictures on doors and I don't think that was the point of the article. I think he wasn't really blaming Brown or the Presvationists, to me it sounded like he was saying they have to work together. I don't think he got into any of the political stuff and to do so would have been wrong so the writer summed it up the best that he could.
I think it is a very positive article and maybe it will get people to come to Buffalo. I think that most of it was pretty much right. You can't expect someone who isn't from Buffalo to get it. It would like if I flew to Chicago (I would like to go see a Black Hawks game and go to Millenium park) To go to Millenium Park and I wrote about there history and that cool reflective globe thing and I acted as if that was the only thing there.