Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

james’s journal

Electoral College Mayhem

· 🌡️ 83°F

I hate the Electoral College


Reading the Federalist Papers years ago, in which the original American argument for the College was put, after a dozen readings I still had no clue why we needed the damn thing. The phrase 'Tyranny of the Majority' comes to mind. However, a sort of Tyranny of the Minority has been the reality.

To illustrate this let's compare the most populace state and the least.

California is home to 33,871,648 people and has 55 electoral votes.

Wyoming is home to 1,689,591 people and has the minimum number of votes at 3.

Now, with some magical math we find that a fair system would give one vote per 563,197 people. But the reality is different. A unit of 563,197 voters should have a single vote. But these varry from state to state.
A single unit in California is equal to .91 votes. Where as in Wyoming a single unit is worth 3.42 votes. Making CA the most under-represented state and WY the most over-represented.

This sucks, but things get a whole lot suckier.

The GOP in CA is fighting for a referendum to drop the winner takes all electoral votes system, which most states use. Instead they want to award an electoral vote to who wins each district. This would give the GOP 20 electoral votes and 35 to the Dems.

This system would be pretty awesome if every state adopted it. Effectively circumventing the swing state morass national politics is in. But by splitting the vote only in CA that would mean it is virtually impossible to elect a Democrat president.

And there is popular support for this in CA! It is a fine idea. A few other states do it, though none are decisive states. But if a key state does it and others don't the result doesn't address any of the problems of the system. Voters are still under represented. Democrats make a majority of voters and they will be under-represented further.

Where do we turn for help! Why, to the moderate GOP Governor Arnold Schwartzeneger! He announced today that he would veto any move to split the electoral vote.

Sometimes help comes from the strangest of places.


355 words

💬 7 comments

  1. joshua ·

    You shouldn't be surprised w/the Governator - he's been accused of being a RINO many, many times. =P

    I think the Electoral College is obsolete. Besides being patently unfair, it forces presidential candidates to concentrate on the states that are "important." The electoral college forces a method of conducting our politics in a way that I find distasteful. Where it does have some use, though, is in ensuring that all the states matter. I don't know if an open general election is appropriate either. I have to be honest, it would frighten me to know that essentially if you placated Californians and those in the east coast and paid no attention to the "flyover" states that someone could be a viable candidate.

    Talk about votes that don't matter - in the city of Buffalo the politics have become so homogenous that candidates from parties other than the Democratic Party are almost completely unviable these days. In our city there are virtually no Democratic candidates that I would support, so how much does my vote matter in the big scheme of things? I am left in the position where I am voting for a sure loser as long as I do not vote for a Democrat.
  2. jason ·

    Wyoming is not infringing on California's right to make sure that Californian votes for Republicans are irrelevant until the end of time. Due to their small size they have basically zero muscle to flex.

    I agree that the proportional system would be great if all states used it. Lots of people in those redneck, hayseed hick states voted for Kerry in 2004. Bush got, correct me if I'm wrong, 40 percent or so in New York State in 2004.

    I haven't ever really bought the whole Tyranny of the Minority thing, and I probably never will.
  3. james ·

    @joshua: oh no, Arnold is my kind of GOP (as opposed to the Brownbacks and Lotts) I am just suprised that he is taking such a tough stance on the issue. I thought Dems were going to have to go on a major EC education campaign.

    I agree with the importance of swing states. It is the same problem with the current primary system. Candidates now spend most of their time in Iowa, NH, and SC. After nominated it is off to OH, FL, PA, and a few others. It is just silly.

    As far as Buffalo goes, I would remind you that our last mayor was a Republican. That aside, you are right. Buffalo politics is fucked.

    @jason. Yes, marginalizing CA GOPers is bad. And I wouldn't be in favor of doing the same in Texas for the same reason. Though CA has gone to Republicans several times before. Since 1968 CA has gone for either party an equal number of times. The political bias of the College changes, but always alienates a large number of people.

  4. jason ·

    Brilliant, we agree! The EC, I understand why they did it but I just don't think we've found the right method yet.
  5. joshua ·

    I usually don't doubt my memory but you made me look it up James! Hehe. Tony Masiello was a Democrat, although in 2001 he did receive joint endorsement from both political parties. Having said what you said it made me think - when is the last time a true Republican was mayor of Buffalo? So, because everything on the internet is true, I looked it up on the internet.

    So finally I found it. The last Republican to hold the Mayor's office was Chet Kowal, who was elected in 1961. In '77 though, Jimmy Griffin lost the Democratic nomination and ran (and won) with the support of the Conservative and Right to Life parties.

    The interesting thing about the site I was looking at (The Buffalonian) was that President Grover Cleveland was not only Mayor of Buffalo but before that he was Sherriff of Erie County. This made him both a police officer and a lawyer... I'll spare the obvious jokes. Unbeknownst to him at the time he was nominated by the Democrats and decided to take the office of Mayor. A little over a year later, he was nominated to be Governor and two years after that he was President of the United States. This is where it all ties in - After his first term, he won the popular vote but lost the electoral college!

    He is also the only President to have been married at the White House, and his bride is still the youngest First Lady ever (21 years old). Also when he was Sherriff of Erie County he conducted hangings himself because he did not want to put the responsibility for something like that on a subordinate.

    Ok that was a ridiculous tangent, but whatever. I'm trying to kill time at work on a Friday.
  6. james ·

    @jason What are your concerns over popular election?

    @joshua: HA! You will have to forgive me. I have only been in this town a few years and find that resources to understand the political scene are either the horrendous complainers or big-headed pundits. I can get by with either on the national scene because I have been following it since I got a subscription to Time magazine in 1991. Buffalo however... I am still in the dark. But since Dems are such an institution here I can see why a Republican would be a good change.... just as long as they leave Planned Parenthood alone ^_^
  7. tinypliny ·

    Picking up on @joshua's ridiculous tangent, what a nice man! Isn't he buried at Forest Lawn?

💬 Write a comment