Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

anne’s journal

Back to Black

· 🌡️ 30°F

Yo why do I keep wanting to write about music? Maybe its because I just got a new (old) iPod and I'm so happy to have music to listen to that isn't one of my 3 CDs I currently own. Getting your hard drive wiped and then iPod stolen is NOT sweet.

I currently need a regular part time job. I work at HSBC Arena but that's only like a few times a month. Of course after the 10 or 15 applications I've filled out, the only one that responds is another job that seems even less consistent than the Arena. Its teaching SAT prep to students. Good for the resume as I'm working towards teaching high school English. Bad because I only got a 540 on math when I took the test in, uhhh, 2002? And my math skills have seriously plummeted since then. Hopefully they're only looking for someone to teach the language arts category and someone else can cover math.

My "oh lord, please don't talk, because when you talk I see how stupid you are" crush, Jesse, WAS in class yesterday but, alas, we were unable to discuss our future together because 1. we did not meet to discuss our presentation and 2. we have no future together.

I like literature (duh), I like talking about it, I enjoy teaching it, I enjoy seeing how different people from different lives react personally to the same text. Even if you have 20 white jewish girls from the 'burbs reading the same book, they have different reactions. In spite of their similar superficial background, they're all different. However, at some point personal reaction can go too far.

In my Contemporary Lit class we're reading a graphic novel called Persepolis by Iranian born writer Marjane Satrapi. I HIGHLY recommend this book, its a super easy read and really gives great insight while striking a balance between "life in Iran" and "life as a woman". There's not a lot of plot to unpack, its straight up, but really interesting.

ANYWAY, the book centers around the Islamic revolution and the instituting of veils and fundamental principles on Iran. Therefore, religion is a strong and powerful overriding theme in the book, its unavoidable and a natural jumping off point for discussion of the book.

This guy in my class who's kind of a toolshed immediately drew a parallel between Islamic fundamentalists and Evangelical Christians. In the United States, the closest thing we have to the dominating outspoken radical religious thinking of Islamic Fundamentalists is Evangelical Christianity. I understand there are others, but at this moment in our history, they're pretty much in our faces all the time. Them and Mormons.

So the toolshed with 2 nose piercings, a really awful lisp and an overall vibe of "I haven't showered lately" starts talking about Evangelical Christianity and basically gets about 2 words out before the girl sitting next to him goes on the attack about how she's an Evangelical Christian and she doesn't like the comparison and basically told him to stop talking about it. The only other time this girl talked in class was to talk about how she voted for McCain and she wanted us to all know that not EVERYONE there voted for Obama. No one assumed that was the truth, btw, but, for the recordm the majority of the class, including the professor, was pro-Obama.

The reason I bring this up is, should the guy have stopped? Was it appropriate for her to ask him to stop because she felt that he was going to generalize? The guy honestly didn't get a whole sentence out, he said basically "In this country, the Evangelical Christians are-" before she cut him off. Should he have continued his comparison? He stopped on his own, the professor did not intervene. Was the girl within her rights to cut him off? Was she being too sensitive? I feel she should've waited to hear what he had to say before just freaking out at those first few words that said nothing of substance about her religion.

What do y'all think. Should she have cut him off the way she did? Was it her right? Should he not have made the connection?

💬 3 comments

  1. drew ·

    As an evangelical Christian, I think she should have kept her mouth shut--by silencing him BEFORE he spoke, she lived into the generalization.

    The guy, on the other hand was correct to stop, because he WAS making a generalization, and one that (increasingly) doesn't hold up. Evangelical Christians do not speak with one voice. Sure, progressives like me are in the minority, but we haven't stopped being Evangelical Christians because we stopped being tools of the Republican party.
  2. jason ·

    A liberal professor....go figure!! Hahaha.

    Honestly, I think her reaction wasn't the best. Of course, nobody can help their feelings. What she SHOULD have done was let him speak his mind, and then just use his poor logic and lack of common sense against him afterwards. It's called giving them enough rope to hang themselves.

    No, I don't think the guy should have stopped. Stifling someone's speech, no matter who it is, isn't our way. I mean he has the right to think and believe what he wants. He has the right to speak and he should have asserted that right. She does not have the right to not be offended. If you hear something that is ludicrous, you fight bad ideas with good ones and check your emotions.
  3. metalpeter ·

    I notice that people seem to think that what he was going to say was wrong, we can't assume that it would be wrong. What if the next thing he was going to say "they get very upset if you say anything about them, and they like to cut people off before the finish there point." He would have been correct. It is also possible that what he was going to say was based on ones that he knows. What she did was stupid. She assumed it was going to be negative and all she did was cause other people to have a sterotype about her. What she should have done is kept her mouth shut since no one was talking to her let him finish and listen to every word. Then chime in with well I'm one and then go into the parts that he got wrong and the parts he got right about some of them. He shouldn't have stopped. What he should have said was I'm sorry if this offends you but this is based on the ones that I have known.

    In terms of the graphic novel, in case you didn't know it was turned into a Animated Movie, and it is supposed to be pretty good, and I've heard it has some pretty good tunes in it.

💬 Write a comment