Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

tinypliny’s journal

Grad school pains

·

Grad school can sometimes be painful.

I like discussing papers at journal club. I read most of them and try to contribute something to the discussion. I may not have the wisest thing to contribute but I try to take away something from every paper we discuss because I feel that 1 hour is my chance to get an insight into how people think when they read papers and how they might view things differently than I do (which is often the case). I really like the process of learning in that hour of journal club.

Students are required to be at the journal club even though they might have a million other things to do. Sometimes it feels like a bother, but in the end I think everyone learns something and also contributes something to the discussion if they spoke up even ONCE during the club. It is almost the nature of science. You cannot be in the thick of it and stop yourself from being involved. Every discussion at journal club is valuable because it is the collective sharing of thoughts that you might not get to hear when you are reading alone.

Faculty, perhaps, play an even more significant role in such journal clubs. They bring to our table their significant experience and expertise in the field. Their comments are almost ALWAYS worth hearing and their input is deeply appreciated. It's that rare hour where students can get an insight into how professionals in their field view any paper and research process.

However, all faculty are not mandated to be at journal clubs if they don't have the time. Since many of them are extraordinarily pressed for time, and have several competing interests, they don't come. Which is fine because if they feel like they have the time to make it, they do contribute to the discussion and that is always beneficial to all the students.

So, it hurts like hell when faculty you admire do turn up to the journal club (supposedly because they could make time for the club in their busy schedule), don't pay any attention to the discussion at the club because they were working right through it and then abruptly get up and leave midway without a word of explanation.

It hurts too much.

I guess it's part of growing up in grad school with faculty and other students subbing for your missing family. The lesson perhaps, is that your interests will never match up with everyone else's at the table and you cannot expect everyone you academically admire to make a trial at mentoring at the club, however brief that hour or even part of that hour might be. What I am really struggling with is do I prefer brutal honesty where the faculty tells you that the paper you picked is an utter waste of time or a completely silent cold approach where they do come but they just leave midway perhaps because they don't think it's worth their time to even say anything.

I think I pick honesty. Silence hurts more than I can express.
Share 515 words · edited Jul 26, 2011

💬 4 comments

  1. leetee ·

    i'm with you. i think silence is more painful. as hurtful as "this sucks" can be, it can also be part of the learning process, future selection processes, or even a hand in helping to direct further attentions. or even if it isn't. sometimes, knowing honestly where someone stands can be liberating.
  2. metalpeter ·

    I don't know enough to comment but I'm going to any ways.

    What if you had all ready put in say 1/3 of work or time into something and a teacher who isn't say your teacher says it stinks as an example would that make someone start all over? But what if your teacher thinks it is great?

    Also is this teacher official.... Say from a Personal standpoint they think it is silly or dull but from the professional side they have a different view.... Cause they aren't in class so it isn't the same thing....

    I'll use an example of me.... At work there are certain things that If I said about someone being lazy or doing stuff wrong or being a bad seed to my boss or a boss could cause all hell to break lose..... Now If I'm at a bar pounding beers or smashing something out side and we are off the clock I could say.... Well trying to kill the pain of that hell hole I work in and forget about all those lazy people.... Then we are off the clock so we could talk and he could give his perspective.... Now on the clock there would be meetings I assume.... But off the clock and away from work it is different is what I was getting at.....
  3. tinypliny ·

    Hmmm... I am not quite sure what you just meant there @metalpeter. ;)
  4. metalpeter ·

    A teacher if they are kinda there just for insight could say different things and give you pointers or what ever as say a reader.... but say they are there as not a guide as your teacher they would kinda be telling you how to write your Paper?

💬 Write a comment