Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

lauren’s journal

Estupido

· · 🌡️ 78°F

Grr. can anyone please tell me why all people wanting to get their PhD must speak at least two, maybe three languages? Maybe, just maybe I am wrong on this...but how many people show "proficiency" on a language exam and then *poof* magically forget how to speak anything beyond, "hola, como esta?" within a week?? This to me is like math. I haven't taken a godam math class since my sophmore year and I rejoiced knowing that I would never have to do it again. The same for my sad and pathetic attempt at German for two semesters. Now don't get me wrong, I would love to be able to speak Spanish. It to me is the most useful in my line of interests, but shouldn't I be focusing on my dissertation? Shouldn't I be past all this standarized test BS?!?! Shouldn't people within the academic world be equally as frustrated and annoyed by this as me? Maybe I am overreacting, but I SUCK at foreign languages just as much as I suck at math. If one were to take all my math, science and foreign language grades off my transcript it would be impeccable. Maybe me scowering through the already limited pool of Women's Studies PhD's for no langauge requirement is pathetic, I don't know. But grr. Grrr.

I feel better.

💬 8 comments

  1. chaibiscoot ·

    Same here, take math, science and language out of my transcripts and it would look/feel so much better. But what is this language requirement for the PhD? New? I speak three languages but Hindi and Telugu probably account for squat, eh? Also, when is the next dance off?
  2. jason ·

    Hmph. Maybe it's just part of what seems, to me at least, to be an effort in Women's Studies to go way out of its way to be multicultural. I don't think it's fair to ask this of you. If you had intended to be a specialist in this way, say if you wanted to focus on women's issues in Latin America, you certainly would have gone that route of your own volition. Instead of forcing this on you, wouldn't it be better overall, and get better results, to let people simply work on what they are passionate about?
  3. james ·

    The language requirement is pretty standard for humanities PhD's. From what I understand you don't need any real fluency. Just be able to translate a piece of writing with a dictionary.

    But good god, what a pain in the ass.
  4. drew ·

    Yeah. I had to learn Greek and Hebrew just for my Masters. If I want at theology Ph.D, I need at least two more languages (even if its in something entirely in English, like black theology.) Bleh.
  5. jim ·

    I was confused Drew, my first thought was that black theology was like, satanist theology. Too much time around @james lol.
  6. museumchick ·

    I know what you mean. I'm trying to relearn some spanish for my proficiency test in the fall.

    It does seems like you shouldn't have to know a language for women's studies unless you were concentrating on an non-english speaking area in your research.
  7. fellyconnelly ·

    so ah... a couple of weeks with pimmsler oughtta do it?
  8. chico ·

    In my PhD program we were able to substitute in statistics and game theory courses to demonstrate proficiency in the technical "language" of stats/formal analysis, but if memory serves the students doing political philosophy or women's studies had to demonstrate proficiency in a foreign language.

    The funny thing is, where my research is right now I wish I had kept studying Spanish...

💬 Write a comment