Category: religion
12/18/08 11:00 - ID#47098
Purpose Driven Life
(e:jim) had a reaction against the Purpose Driven Life, a book by Rick Warren:
This quote was singled out in particular:
This spiritual servitude only has negative connotations in a culture that is obsessed with asserting the rights of the individual. Civil rights, human rights, gay rights, minority rights-we hear about this constantly. Instead of asserting our rights-even if we have the freedom to do so-we are choosing to set them aside for a greater thing: the opportunity to serve the living God. What are you setting aside in order to serve God?
I believe that Rick Warren here is right, but incompletely right, and wrong, but incompletely wrong. I will explain.
Christians are called to put others ahead of themselves, and to put God's will ahead of theirs. Because we are often selfish, this is good for the world, and good for us (when we actually try it, but that's another post).
We get this idea, of course, from Jesus. We believe that Jesus had every authority, every "right" and yet refused to assert those rights violently. He gave up his rights, and suffered, even though he was innocent.
And Christians are called to follow his way.
But that doesn't mean that Christian blacks had to be content with seperate and unequal. When Dr. King organized the Bus Boycott, he asserted the right to ride the bus by NOT riding the bus. Christianity, done right, exposes the selfishness of the systems of this world for what they are. In Selma, that meant that police were trying to FORCE men and women onto the bus.
So we do assert our rights, as individuals and as a group--Warren is wrong when he implies that Christians cannot be involved in standing up for individual/minority rights. But it's NOT about asserting our rights. It's about giving up our rights for others.
The biggest problem with the civil rights movement wasn't the actions of black Christians, it was the silence of white Christians. We stood by (for the most part) and refused to give up our rights for others. Comfortable silence is un-Christian. "That's their problem" is un-Christian.
So Warren is right that it isn't about us. But he removes the speck from the eyes of minority Christians, and (in this quote) forgets to mention the efforts of white (mostly) Christians to protect their rights to put up the 10 commandments, pass laws, avoid taxes, or whatever.
Now Warren, though he is far from perfect. DOES give up much of his rights. He never sees 90% of the money he makes, because it goes straight to Africa. Think about that before you criticize to harshly, because at the very least, the man is committed. How many other New York Times Best Selling Authors live in little houses in the city? While I would love to be able to give as much as he does, I might buy a nice car or cable tv first. Warren puts his money where his mouth is.
So he's right: We are supposed to give up our rights, but incompletely, because he didn't hit the "sacred cows" of the rights of majority Christians.
And he's wrong: We can and do and should assert our rights (Jesus did), but at least he not completely wrong, because the ironic way of claiming our rights is to lose them in public ways that expose the foolishness of those who take them.
Permalink: Purpose_Driven_Life.html
Words: 580
Location: Buffalo, NY
Category: football
12/16/08 08:58 - 18ºF - ID#47078
AFC North Champions
Permalink: AFC_North_Champions.html
Words: 12
Location: Buffalo, NY
Category: christmas
12/15/08 11:41 - 50ºF - ID#47066
December 24, 8pm
I'm done with gentle invites. I'm going with double entendre from here on out.
Lafayette Church
elmwoodjesus.org
Permalink: December_24_8pm.html
Words: 20
Location: Buffalo, NY
Category: drugs
12/12/08 03:42 - 29ºF - ID#47044
Being on drugs . . .
Of course, it is only the performance of my mind, so it is legal.
After much delay and testing, I finally got a perscription to help me with ADHD. So far, I am happy with it, although I am not sure one day of work and one day off are enough to test it.
Here's what I noticed. First of all, the con:
Yesterday, I took my doses (10mg, twice a day) too close together. That led to a bit of time where I felt like I had too much coffee.
Pros:
Similar to what (e:jim) expressed: I can choose what i pay attention to. This is huge, and I have noticed it already. I stayed on task in a budget meeting, read a book without getting up to check email/walk around/cook/eat (and yes, that has been my normal way of reading) and went to bed when I chose (par for the course is to get REALLY tired as I constantly surf the internet/watch tv).
It's wierd, but really the most amazing thing is my ability to walk away from the computer. The bad thing about web 2.0 is that there is always the possiblity of feedback, and I am a feedback junkie. There is also always something new, but now I am not so desperate as to constantly check back to sites to see if something new has come up.
I think I am going to exercise today, because being able to pay attention and make choices has freed up the time/motivation to do so. We'll see if that keeps up.
Finally, (and this is supposed to be a negative side effect, but for me it is good) I think my appetite is lower. We'll have to see about this, because I really do like food. Also, sometimes I eat out of restlessness, so the meds might help with that anyway.
Another Con: I do feel a little bit different, in a way that is hard to describe. It's like I am not totally out of my head, but I am zoomed out just one more step, and I am observing myself a little bit more instead of just being myself. That probably makes me sound crazy. But there is just a little bit more distance between myself and my reading/typing/conversation/whatever. I'm not sure it is so bad yet, but it feels wierd, and I was hoping that I would feel the same but be able to organize myself and stop losing things.
It will be interesting to see what I am like on Sunday and for a full work week.
Permalink: Being_on_drugs_.html
Words: 446
Location: Buffalo, NY
Category: football
12/08/08 04:18 - 25ºF - ID#46998
YLDS: Stillers win again
Also, I am proud to be a big part of "football" showing up in the tag could on the front page of estrip.org.
Permalink: YLDS_Stillers_win_again.html
Words: 54
Location: Buffalo, NY
Category: football
12/02/08 11:42 - 28ºF - ID#46930
Yinz luv da stillers--no fun league ed.
Permalink: Yinz_luv_da_stillers_no_fun_league_ed_.html
Words: 10
Location: Buffalo, NY
Category: 10 things
12/02/08 10:31 - 32ºF - ID#46920
10 Things I like about the economy
1. People are growing in their empathy. For many of us, people in poverty are no longer "them," they are "us."
2. Gas prices have come down.
3. This will get us to do things differently.
4. We will have learned that ridiculous debt is ridiculous.
5. People should end up happier. Statistically, people are more likely to be happy when they have less disposable income (as long as basic needs are met).
6. What goes down, should come up? Maybe? Right?
7. (e:vincent)'s cogent analysis.
8. I expect to be able to find some used skis super cheap.
9. The best things in life are still free.
10. My grandparents prepared me well for living in a depression.
Permalink: 10_Things_I_like_about_the_economy.html
Words: 142
Location: Buffalo, NY
Category: 10 things
11/24/08 04:25 - 36ºF - ID#46820
10 Things I like about Xmas decorating
1. Spending time with people I like.
2. Snacking while I work.
3. The moment when you turn off the overhead lights and look at the glow.
4. Trying to take low-light pictures of the tree.
5. The smell of a fresh tree.
6. It only comes once a year.
7. Happy memories.
8. The celebratory cold one at the end.
9. The fact that other people do a lot of the work.
10. This year, the churches decorations DO NOT include a live tree--which makes my life a lot easier.
Permalink: 10_Things_I_like_about_Xmas_decorating.html
Words: 100
Location: Buffalo, NY
11/22/08 10:42 - 25ºF - ID#46794
Good onion story/my roots
Permalink: Good_onion_story_my_roots.html
Words: 6
Location: Buffalo, NY
11/21/08 09:57 - 23ºF - ID#46792
Say it ain't so!
Permalink: Say_it_ain_t_so_.html
Words: 26
Location: Buffalo, NY
Author Info
Date Cloud
More Entries
My Fav Posts
- This user has zero favorite blogs selected ;(
Notice how these people (like Warren) expect _others_ to sacrifice for them.
So when their religion discriminates against others, they expect the others to not stand up for their rights.
When was the last time the Church gave up something to benefit people outside the flock?
Consider the marriage issue. It would have been something if the Church had said "OK, we don't like the idea that 'marriage' deems lots of legal rights; lets separate that out". But they did not.
To me, it is apparent that the Church's opposition to gay marriage is nothing to do with the whole 'man + woman' thing; but it has everything to do with denying the gays the right to enjoy their "lifestyle". It's a simple case of revenge: we can't prevent you from committing acts of sin, so we'll make you pay for it in other ways.
Anyway, yeah. Christians get a bad rep about a lot of things. And it's not applicable to all christians. But how many really stand up to others in the context of their own faith in other to change that?
Is it a case of "Not us. Not our problem."?
At the core of conventional christianity is a belief in hell. Because of hell, it is every christian's "mission" to save others. Very specific things are believed to send someone to hell. And a number of them are in direct contradiction with the desired, and thought to be "inalienable", rights of a good number of ethical people.
"Purpose #5: You Were Made for a Mission (Mission)"
If certain elements of the "mission" of such a large force is in direct contradiction to how you want to live your life, can you really be expected to respect that "mission" in any way?
Note that "tolerance", as currently practiced, is just an easy way out of having to deal with these issues. Those showing real tolerance would not attempt to force society to define a concept only according to their guidelines. (ie. Marriage) Those showing real tolerance would put more effort into teaching their own the same than in attempting to keep as many as possible on their "side". But, that's the "mission".
Yeah, I caught that NPR bit about Carlton Pearson... Interesting stuff. There's only a couple people in the world-wide clergy that I respect more at this point.
Yes, there are valuable and good lessons to be found from within religion. Still, religion isn't the only source for these lessons.
If Warren was serious about 'serving others' and 'giving up his rights', he would have opposed Proposition 8.
I would write a longer response, but I have to go now. More later...