Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

lauren’s journal

Bizzaro

· · 🌡️ 91°F

Ok, I want it to be known, first of all, that I am writing this more for my own pleasure and release than out of an expectance that others will read this, let alone enjoy it or be fascinated by it.

Ok, so this terribly boring liberal feminist philisopohical type book I am reading is by a woman named Martha Nussbaum who is apparently some big shit in the academic world. Wooopty Doo. I decided to cheat a little and look up some critiques of her work in hopes of wrapping my mind around what exactly it is that she is talking about and I found this fascinating little tidbit of info:

"Martha's Protestant father was horrified by her decision at N.Y.U. to marry a Jew named Alan Nussbaum, a linguist she met in a class on Greek prose composition. But she was an eager convert. "I had an intense desire to join the underdogs and to fight for justice in solidarity with them," she has written. For Nussbaum, Judaism offered a sense of community lacking in her own upbringing."

Now, I might be wrong here, but isn't this like, really fucked up? Did she really love this man or had she simply fallen in love with the idea of being an "underdog"?? Was this her pathetic attempt to dissolve her own priveledges and to feel like she was more worthy of attacking oppression, because by marrying a Jew and converting to Judaism, she too could now join the ranks of an oppressed group? This to me, sounds similar to women who, during the 2nd wave of feminism "converted" to lesbianism not because they loved other women in a romantic way, but because it was seen as a political necessity because sleeping with a man was sleeping with the enemy. Gross.

Maybe I am being over dramatic, ridiculous, I don't know. but something about it just scratches at my very core and I can't quite get it to go away.

💬 6 comments

  1. drew ·

    yeah. wierd. Although having hung out with many lame protestants, I can understand being eager to convert. But if she was so eager, why wait for marriage? Kind of anti-feminist if you ask me--"I can't start with a new faith unless I have a man to usher me into it."

    And if she really was into the whole underdog thing, she would have realized that Jesus was a pretty big fan of underdogs, too.

    As for lesbians converting out of "politcal necessity," all I can wonder is, does that work as a pick-up line?

    "Look, I know you may not want to come home with me, but its a political necessity."
  2. joshua ·

    The whole thing is offensive to me - the reasons appear to be completely wrong and irrational. Do you agree? Maybe I'm wrong but it seems to me that this is a bit of a mockery and isn't going to actually help anybody that is struggling for equality. This sort of thing is done purely for selfish reasons.

    I love feminists - the one girl that I was attracted to the most but never had the guts to ask out (I dated her best friend, I hear there's a rule against that) was a feminist. Of course I'm only referring to rational feminists... not women who strictly hate men for being men and are really aggressive and militant.
  3. fellyconnelly ·

    drew.... how did you know that's how i picked up lauren? you are psychic.

    and joshua - there is a rule about dating friends of exes but if i had stuck to that rule, i wouldn't have spent the last two and a half years with lauren. well... that and the whole political neccessity thing.
  4. ladycroft ·

    Well it 'sounds' like she was happy to convert so she could belong to a particular group, but do we know the original context from which that quote was taken?
  5. fellyconnelly ·

    Ok, so first of all @joshua I would like to take the time to point out that I have never met a militant man hating feminist or lesbian for that matter. This is, in my opinion, an image of feminism that is used as a tool against women who want to identify as such. I think it has resulted in many women shying away from the term because they don't want to be seen a man hating lesbians. Most feminists have fathers, brothers, sons, uncles, male friends, gay male friends, boyfriends etc who are indeed male and they love them and cherish them. I know that there were some exclusionary feminists and probably still are some, but they are certainly not the majority and in my opinion they aren't doing anyone any good except themselves which to me, is anti-feminist. I get offended when feminists are referred to like this because I am a feminist, many of my friends are feminist, and allign my politics with feminism, and this does not in anyway reflect the reality of the feminism I know.

    Moving on, I am glad to see that I am not the only one who interpreted this excerpt in this way. True, I do not know what the context was and true, she is no longer with this man (perhaps because she only loved his religion??) I don't know, but at the same time I can see it all fitting togther so nicely. Nice, educated, straight, middle class woman wants to feel a little more oppressed so what does she do? Convert to Judaism!! Sounds easy enought to me.
  6. lauren ·

    ahh poopy. For those who couldn't tell that was NOT felly, that was meeeeeee!!

💬 Write a comment