Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

drew’s journal

Is religion harmful?

· · 🌡️ 62°F

Short answer: yes. As seen in the post that inspired this, from last week by @paul, it is perfectly clear. Add abortion clinic bombings, terrorism, and the crusades, and it's simple. Religion brings all kinds of problems into this world.

Then, why, pray tell (haha! pun!) would I so involved in religion?

There's a few reasons: In no particular order--

a. (using letters so this is not confused with my "10 things lists") We are, by nature, religious people. By saying this I mean to say that we are all prone to ask questions about meaning for our life, and we are all likely to give ourselves in worship. I believe that even those of us that deny the existence of GOD have other "gods," because we need them. My devotion to u2 and to the Steelers is borderline religious. I know that is pathetic, but I offer it up as an example. Our tendencies to ask "why," to connect with other people, and to give ourselves to something bigger than ourselves are religious tendencies.

b. Religion is still a force for good. Ironically, religious people invented the ideas of religious tolerance and of the separation of church and state. Although we have been on the wrong side of these issues, too, Christians were the driving force behind most of the positive progressive social movements in this country.

c. The best cure for bad religion is not "no religion," but "good religion." This is just my opinion, of course, but I think that the best way to help Christians that behave badly is not to ask them to abandon their devotion (unlikely, to say the least) but to show them a truer picture of the one they are devoted to. I really do believe that the best picture of true justice and true grace is found in Jesus as shown in the Bible. Name calling, threatening encounters such as the one that @paul had to deal with are, to put it simply, inconsistent with how Christians are called to act. Good religion seeks the best, not for itself exclusively, but especially for its non-adherents.

d. Personal experience. I know that this is different for everybody, but based on what I know and what I've experienced, I believe that God exists, that he existed on earth in the person of Jesus Christ, and that those statements affect everything about the way that I live my life. I COULD try to make sense of those things on my own, but I am better off trying to do so with other people, and that's the seed of religion.

I think my next post will be a guide for non-believers and believers to deal with scary people of faith.

💬 10 comments

  1. james ·

    It is a little over-reaching to say that religion is a force for good or for bad when, like everything else in this world, it has mounds of both. Religious institutions do a lot of good. They help people in need, though I question the ultimate benefit of faith, and so I am willing to let it go.

    Ya, Fred Phelps is an ass and Pat Robertson... makes you wonder if Christ would even recognize his religion as his own with these clowns.

    But odd things like Mother Theresa crusading against condoms in nations with high rates of AIDS infections. Or the Dalai Lama raising money to fund Tibetan separatist militias... it is disheartening.

    The world would be a much better place if all followers of religion were more like those they are following. In the meantime we will just be grateful for the folks that aren't the Freds and pats of the world.
  2. janelle ·

    "But odd things like Mother Theresa crusading against condoms in nations with high rates of AIDS infections. Or the Dalai Lama raising money to fund Tibetan separatist militias... it is disheartening".
    It's a very human attribute to fall from the ultimate standard or to have inconsistencies in belief. Religious folks aren't immune from that attribute. Xtians might attribute it to the sinful nature of man, but I'll defer to preacher man on that.

    "The world would be a much better place if all followers of religion were more like those they are following."
    I'd like to say yes to that statement, but I can't. I think it's because it's an easy statement on the surface, but difficult in practice. First, see above, all humans fall short of the perfect standard. Second, some of the individuals whom we might say are examples of what makes religion dangerous, believe they ARE like that religious figure they are trying to follow. Third, I say I'm following Christ, but so does the guy who bombs the abortion clinic.

    I'm curious, @jim, but you don't have to answer... You make the statement that the world would be a much better place if followers of religion were more like those they follow, but you also say you question the ultimate benefit of faith. How do you reconcile those two ideas ? ...or do you just accept that they are contradictory? ... Or you haven't figured out a way to reconcile them? (In vietnam, it's okay to have two contrary ideas, it's just a different way of processing information)

  3. janelle ·

    so sorry, James, I called you @jim. you can spit at me or something next time you see me. lol.
  4. james ·

    The two are not contradictory. The benefits of religion are not necessarily religious in nature. That is, a religious institution can do positive things whether or not there is any legitimacy to their spiritual doctrine. If god didn't exist that soup kitchen or support group is still equally useful. Coming from a point of view that there is no such legitimacy I am uneasy with people prescribing to a world view that is false. However, I also recognize that human perception is infinitely small and that no one can grasp the ultimate reality. So, once again, I am willing to let is go.

    "Third, I say I'm following Christ, but so does the guy who bombs the abortion clinic."

    Under any sort of scrutiny the guy who blows people up is not following Christ, just as the Muslim car-bomber is not following Allah. They may view their acts as divinely sanctioned, and so consider themselves followers of their god, but seriously, have they even read the book? Where this sort of unhinges itself is that the laws prescribed in these holy books are attached to the cultures of Abraham's, Christ's, and/or Mohammed's time. The old testament LOVES the capital punishment. Talmudic law does not. Jesus turns the other cheek. Crusaders kill in his name. etc, etc. In the struggle to not be outdated one has to redact modernity from an ancient tome. Which certainly causes problems when the same book tells you to love your neighbor and kill your Shia neighbor.

    That is why I don't put my faith into the literature of long dead men but in man's capacity for change. As a historian I certainly appreciate dialogue with the past through records like the Bible. But also as a historian I hope that the lessons pulled from that text is set in a modern context of compassion. And if you can do that I don't care if the text is about Jesus, Krishna, or Mighty Taco.
  5. janelle ·

    @james:
    "Third, I say I'm following Christ, but so does the guy who bombs the abortion clinic."
    I guess the point I was trying to make with the above statement is everyone constructs their own view of their religious follower and their method for understanding religious texts. Those methods and constructions are influenced by our personality, intelligence and environment. Even you have indicated a method for doing so, it seems largely based on your education in history, and you have made a determination that someone who blows people up is not following Christ or Allah. So naturally, people are going to have different views of Christ, Allah, etc...and thus follow them differently and that will sometimes lead to conflict and issues and it's a constant struggle for those faith communities. I guess my overall point is that your statement in your first comment is easier said than done for religious communities and I was trying to flesh out some of those difficulties.

    I still think it's contradictory to promote religion for its benefits while ultimately questioning the legitimacy of religion. Especially, since you could theoretically have no religious institution and still have soup kitchens. But I probably think this way because from my perspective I believe in the legitimacy of my faith as well as the benefits of my faith.

    Thanks for the challenging dialogue =)

  6. james ·

    I do not think that it is contradictory. I personally do not believe that religious doctrine is legitimate. However, there certainly are scores of people who do. I am totally cool with their personal beliefs so long as it does not harm anyone or pollute the public interest. Which is why religious communities that work towards social good are cool shit and people like James Dobson are stinky jerks.
  7. janelle ·

    Hm, I guess I'll call it a draw on the contradictory argument. It was the least interesting of all of our discussion to me anyway, but it's so damn hard for me to walk away from even the littlest of arguments! But here I am.... w.a..l...k....i.....n......g away!
    LOL I need that little walk icon from the chat box.
  8. metalpeter ·

    The dangerous side of religion is that most people who follow there belief system believe that what they are doing is right. That could be a person who thinks Abortion is killing and killing is wrong but that killing everyone in an abortion clinc is ok. The other danger is that I think a lot of people use there religion to back up or to enforce the moral belief system they all ready have. So for example if they think women are inferior they can use the story of Adam & Eve and how women was created from Adams rib as a way to say women are inferior. Often times people believe that their way is the only way and anyone who doesn't think the way they are is evil and is going to hell, and in some cases that they should die.

    To me it does seem that often religion is used to devide people instead of bringing them togather. Again I think it is people using it to do that not the religion its self. I sort of get what I think it was @james said that people should act more like the leaders. In other words when I go to do something I shouldn't do what the church would have me do, I should do what Jesus would do, or at least what I think he would do. That same idea can be applied to other religions to. I think that people should remember that they are being taught be people and not these other very powerfull profets and take that into consideration when they learn things, but most people don't.

    I do just want to add that religion does have a lot of good points to but that isn't what the post was about so that is why I'm not getting into them.
  9. drew ·

    Everybody justifies their own behavior, right? religious people use their religion, but other people use other things, right? I mean, almost nobody really believes that what they do is bad.

    Of course, this doesn't make sense, because there are a lot of bad people in this world, some believers, some not. But ask any person if they are good, and even most of the worst offenders will say "yes," and offer an excuse for their behavior.

    Maybe this is why I like my particular faith, because it encourages me to examine my own choices based not on what I think is good, but on some exterior standard. (I'm sure that some other faiths do this, but I can only speak to my own experience).

    Where do problems come up? When that standard is distorted, or used on others, rather than on one's self. Or when the inability to meet the standard drives a person to desperation.

    For me, the best cure is a religious one: self-examination, confession, and then forgiveness. Repeat until death, hopefully with less to confess each time (but don't count on it--see the posts about mother Theresa!).
  10. lizabeth ·

    Drew, if you've found the impetus for self-examination in Christianity, that's great, but I'm afraid it doesn't work that way for everyone. One of my biggest problems with religion is that it so often seems to allow people to turn their critical thinking skills off instead of helping them hone those skills.

    "Why do we do things the way we do?"
    "Well, because it says so in this really old book."
    "What's so special about this book? How do we know this book is right?"
    "Well, because we got this book from God."
    "How do you know?"
    "Because we just do. Stop asking stupid questions."

    And the discussion just ends there. Too many people use their religion as an excuse for not thinking deeply about what they believe and what they do. They just go along with whatever because it's tradition, or because it's what everyone else they know does. I don't think this blind adherence to a belief system does anyone any favors.

💬 Write a comment