Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

maureen’s journal

Education in America

· 🌡️ 45°F

Tomorrow night John Stossell is doing a special on education in America (10pm on 20/20, I think it's on abc?) . It looks really interesting but really slanted. Apparently he is arguing for a voucher system for all schools, not just private. The fact is, the longer American students stay in our schools the more they fall behind students in other countries. In fourth grade our kids match up with kids in Belgium and by high school we are years behind. It's scary when you think about it, and since I started grad school that's all I've been thinking about. There is no simple answer to fixing our schools. The inequalities of our educational system are really appalling (for anyone interested an amazing book came out recently on the issue by Jonathan Kozol called The Shame of the Nation). I have great respect for teachers, but the profession is really not set up for quality control at all. Furthermore, schools do not implement research findings that could improve student achievement. Developing literacy programs has become a business and marketing agencies have better success at getting districts to buy their packaged programs that education schools. And don't get me started on the enormous mess that is No Child Left Behind (this statement is purely from an educational researcher's point of view, and not based on politics). Of all of the government services provided, it is my (biased) view that education is the most important AND least successful. In any event, I will be watching, or at least taping, the special tomorrow night.

💬 5 comments

  1. joshua ·

    The educational system is a mess, but its not for a lack of funding. Washington, D.C. spends approximately $10,000 per student per year, but consistently ranks as one of the poorest systems in the nation.

    I think the solution is to actually enforce stringent standards - in the USA right now the "feel good crowd" is in. Its easy to see that standards are secondary to self-esteem.
  2. ajay ·

    Over the years, two things have happened.

    On the left side, the teachers have unionized and are always bitching about explicit or perceived slights (and yes, the pay isn't that great either; but blame the unions for that, AFAIK).

    On the right side, the Religious Right has been hacking away at the roots of the educational system, upset by the fact that their kids could be taught about scary things like Evolution and Birth Control.

    We need a middle ground. There's no lack of funds. City of Buffalo spends $10K/year per child. That is a _lot_ of money. I say they should give the teachers raises while firing the unqualified/unmotivated ones; and pay for this by cutting back on the administrative overheads. There are just too many layers of bureaucracy. Also, teachers need to realise that they have to work with the kids that they get. If the kids are coming from broken families and are lacking, then they just have to work harder.
  3. jim ·

    City school districts tend get stuck with the most expensive students. Special needs, medical services, kids with serious disabilites. The average for the district is $10k per child, but the median is ridiculously lower. The vast majority of students aren't getting anywhere near $10k worth of education.
  4. joshua ·

    I'm watching the Stossel piece while sitting here in my hotel in Seattle. The bottom line is that he's right about the system as it is. To say that its a system that works is an absolute joke.

    I tend to agree with Ajay's outlook on the solution to the problem, although it really isn't a political issue. Ultimately money isn't going to solve the problem, and I think that our schools could learn alot about improving education by looking at what schools that outperform ours are doing.

    Theres a reason why teachers unions and public education officials are afraid of competition.
  5. metalpeter ·

    I watched it last night and it was very interesting. However there are a couple things that they didn't touch on that if they had more time should have been mentioned. The first is the importance of schooling. It is my belief that it is taken much more seriously in other countries then here, that is one big factor to why they are so far ahead. I think competion between schools is a good idea. But I don't understand vochers. You give a kid money so that they can go to another school. But shouldn't all kids get them and be able to go to better schools. But if you did that for everyone why not just improve the schools they are at. In any event it was verry interesting.

💬 Write a comment