Skip to the posts
Buffalo's neighborhood journals since 2003 🍀 Patrick Spicy Devil Logan🌭 Sahlen🥨 Weber Spank🥟 Pierogi🐸 Scaj🍺 Labatt Utica Pink Cherio❄️ Snow Murder

YesThatCasey’s journal

Hetero/homonormativity

((Edit: apparently this isn't coming across as I intended. The point of the post was to begin a discussion on these concepts. This is not intended to be an attack on anyone.))

These two terms are still in the growing stages and, as a result, seem to vary in what I’ve read. I’ll provide a short (and perhaps poor) summary on the part that is currently important to me:

Homonormativity asserts that everybody with any lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender (homosexual) connection is and acts as if they were homosexual.

Heteronormativity asserts that heterosexuals fall within traditional gender roles and attitudes.

More reading, if so inclined:

Homonormativity

Heteronormativity

At this point in my life I am surrounded by gay friends. I have 2 circles of largely gay friends, and another circle of every-type-of-bisexuality friends. I don’t really have any strictly straight circles that I’m around with any regularity. My two closest friends are gay.

This isn’t something that I think about much. It doesn’t matter to me. I don’t hang out with people because of their sexuality; I hang out with them because I think they are good people and I enjoy their company, and hopefully that feeling is reciprocal.

But, occasionally, and especially recently, I find that my sexuality is being questioned.

I am straight. But, since I am often in gay bars with my gay friends, and not ‘acting’ as straight as most other straight people, and not walking around with a girl on my arm, the notion that I can be straight seems to be difficult to grasp.

This is nowhere near the first time I have faced this attitude. I generally take it as a compliment; I hear ‘you are an individual’. That’s cool with me. I have fun joking around with it; pushing the line where I can for entertainment’s sake.

It’s more difficult to do that when a person’s attitude towards you changes just because you aren’t what they think you should be.

I don’t care that my personality doesn’t match what people think it should for a straight person. I’m damn well not going to act differently just because someone thinks I need to in order to prove who I am. It pisses me off that a person who belongs to a group that is still frequently persecuted, and who I have fought for regardless of the fact that I myself am not directly included in that group, is then going to turn around and give me attitude because I don’t fit in a particular mold. Insinuating that I’m not being honest, either with others or myself, is really insulting.

How is it that humans so consistently, and quickly, lose sight of the place we just left?
Share 470 words · edited Jan 13, 2012

💬 24 comments

  1. tinypliny ·

    eh? very confusing post.
  2. metalpeter ·

    I won't lie I didn't follow the links of the terms and maybe I should but I'm bit confused on what they mean..... But I don't agree with the first term at all... Now that I think about it the second term I don't agree with either....

    Of course I can't prove this but I think that there are men and women who might par take it say couples sex... They date and act what ever Straight is but the sex would be gay... So that kinda bashes Term #1.... Maybe this only is aimed at men but how does a bi girl and a straight act differently? Now where this term might get some credence is if one argues that there isn't really and such thing as a man who is Bi they are really gay but just don't really know it and that Denial is so strong they can't over come it....

    Now if you believe term #2... That means that if you don't follow Gender Roles you are gay? Not buying that either... So you have no Job and so you watch the kids and the wife makes the money... Then you are gay? Or if you prefer
    Soccer in this country.... I don't buy it......
  3. YesThatCasey ·

    What's confusing Tiny?
  4. metalpeter ·

    Now in terms of being Bothered in bars Not sure what to tell yeah.... Make you gay friends to Straight bars and make them wait an hour to get then when they do get in listen to the same music and dance? HA....

    I think the real issue or one of them might be the deception... Not that you do it on purpose... But the thinking aka Assuming everyone there is gay... Kinda like if some one gay was at a bar drinking and talking about the game and this and that and then came onto them... It isn't this is gross (Yes that could be a part of it) but it is that you think this person is one thing and they are another.... But again just a guess... Kinda Like when you go some place to eat think it is cool think it is your place list them as the best everything in art voice and then 2 months later the chef you talked to and thought was the owner isn't cause the place is a national chain ?

    Hoping I'm not the only one to chime in.... Hey on the brightside? be glad you are being hit on? The one time I went out I wasn't even noticed in either type of bar so......
  5. YesThatCasey ·

    Peter, the terms are negative. They are unreasonable constraints that people place on others or themselves.
  6. metalpeter ·

    With more time I do want to read up on them.... I do agree that they both are negative.... With any new terms or information one or at least I have to think a bit.....
  7. YesThatCasey ·

    My point is clearly being missed. This has nothing to do with people hitting on me. That doesn't bother me. I'd suggest reading the links. This has to do with forcing people into particular roles.
  8. paul ·

    Wow I must gave really fallen off the gossip wagon to have missed whatever started this.

    I can't even count the number of responses I wrote to this and deleted.
  9. YesThatCasey ·

    Bah, this is clearly not coming across as I intended. Unfortunately, I don't know how to clear it up because I don't know what people are thinking when they are reading it.

    Maybe the part where I'm expressing my frustration is being viewed as an attack or something, but that's not the case. It was more to convey how these attitudes can make me feel when I or people I know are targeted by them.

    The intention of my OP was to point out is that there are cultural tendencies to identify attitudes as belonging to particular groups, but that these tendencies are misplaced, unhelpful, and anti-progressive. The growing acceptance of homosexuality has been accompanied by the notion that these somewhat distinct groups have distinct characteristics. Instead, both sides need to remember that this is about allowing people to be whatever it is they want to be. Not just sexually, but in any form of expression.

    I suppose this all started after a discussion at game night. My sexuality came up, and TK took the common position that I was gay, something he adamantly believes. Others had more interesting positions, with the Kinsey scale coming up for example. I found it humorous for the most part, but the underlying frustration as I later thought through it led me to start researching these lines of thought. I came across the aforementioned concepts for the first time, and thought they were good starting point for a discussion.

    This isn't a matter of drama. I'm just sharing my thoughts without editing them since I feel e-strip is a more intimate grounds for discussion. There aren't any reasons to delete responses. I was just interested on peoples thoughts on this matter. I guess now I'm also interested in what made my post come across so differently, heh.
  10. lauren ·

    Ok, first I want to clarify the meaning of heteronormativity. Heteronormativity is the assumption that ALL people are straight and are therefore treated as such... for example, when I walk into a GYN office and they are flabbergasted that I'm not on birth control or people look at my wedding ring and ask about my husband. Heteronormativity ignores or erases the possibility that people may be something other than straight and is akin to racism in the sense that it is culturally and systematically embedded in the way we think, act, and treat people.

    So, that being said, I think the link you gave for the definition of homonormativity is lacking and probably misleading. I found this: HOMONORMATIVITY - ‘A politics that does not contest dominant heteronormative assumptions and institutions, but upholds and sustains them, while promising the possibility of a demobilized gay constituency and a privatized, depoliticized gay culture anchored in domesticity and consumption’ ( L. Duggan 2003 ). So I think what it's saying is that in gay culture homonormativity is the internalization by the gay community of values and stereotypes of what it means to be gay which belong to/have been created by the straight community.

    Ug, I have run out of time and have to get ready for work, but thanks for the post, I have been out of the academic loop and haven't heard this term "homonormativity" yet. Interesting concept.
  11. tinypliny ·

    @lauren, I miss your posts and you glamourous husband's, you (e:strip) traitors!
  12. tinypliny ·

    Comment #67174 --> ohhhhh! I see now. yes, that resolves some confusion.

    My solution: Who cares?! You are who you are - straight, gay, bi, tri, confused, stressed, whatever. People will think whatever they want to. The trick is to stand back and enjoy the gossip. ;-)
  13. tinypliny ·

    PS: I intentionally wrote I was trisexual-on-a-metaphysical-scale on a super-serious official questionnaire recently. It was so much fun! :)
  14. paul ·

    I deleted my responses for political reasons. I was not sure who started it so I didn't want to say anything till I knew. I will write a bigger response as soon as I am at a keyboard.
  15. tinypliny ·

    OOOOH!! Bring on the bigger responsE!
  16. flacidness ·

    its not that that i don't appreciate individuality because i do, more than you would know. My problem is when you complain that you don't get any "Straight" women to be around or sleep with. and you won't if you surround yourself with only gay boys and go to only gay bars. You can totally be around whomever you want but when you're saying certain things and doing other things that "normal" straight guys wouldn't do and i won't go into details. It's gonna make me think and wonder what you're true agenda is. You know know you don't have to prove your sexuality to anybody it's nobodies business but your own, but don't expect people to feel sorry for you and your sex life when you are doing nothing to fix it yourself. I'm gonna stop here because i don't want to say too much. This is a conversation you and i should have had and not posted first.
  17. paul ·

    By polictical reasons, I just meant I wanted to find out the backstory first so I didn't end up in the middle of an argument between two friends. Even this time I found myself deleting so much. I have become a self-censored person. I never wanted to be this way - I am going to have to work on it.

    Here is one good non-sexual reason that a straight man might surround himself with gay people. It might really have more to do with gay people generally having more free time and less risk aversion due to lack of children. It seems that is still a primary goal of yours. I mean you have even more gay friends than I do. You also have more free time. Maybe there is correlation?

    That being said, it is hard for me to understand not being attracted to either sex. I guess it all comes down to nothing grosses me out. I feel that once I bond with someone there is a distinct possibility I am going to want to have sex with them. You can pretty much ask any friend I ever had. Gender doesnt play a big role in this. This doesnt mean I have gotten with every friend I ever had, but I probably thought about it if they cross a certain attractiveness threshold and closeness. Some people say this makes me a whore. I don't care.

    Looking back my early sexuality 12-15 was greatly influenced by a whole bunch of circle jerks with a bunch of different groups of guys. I didn't consider those gay experiences because multiple people were involved and straight porn or dares was the driving factor.

    Around age 15 I started having sex with women. I had a lot of sex from 15-20. Its a miracle that I did not become a teen father. Honestly, during that time I really didn't think about guys in a sexual way. I can't decide if it was because I was repressing it or just not feeling it. Based on some journals I found, I think religion might have played a role. That wasn't to say guys were not hitting on me.

    It wasnt until I was 20 and in Germany that I had my first bromosexual experience. I met this guy who very similar. We both had casual girlfriends at the time. We spend a lot of time together - dancing, smoking pot, hiking around the city, the beach, etc. All my favorite things. We were bros. He was so hot, I know this not just based on personal preference but because every girl wanted him.

    One time we went dancing and afterwards I crashed at his place. We were just laying around listening to NWA when this song came on :::link::: If you dont know the song just listen because it all makes much more sense afterwards. I immediately noticed he had a boner in his tight black levis 501s. I reached over and a few minutes later I found out what an uncircumsized dick is all about.

    After that, there were no more barriers and pretty much anyone was a possible target for my sexual desires. I found most guys, regardless of their sexual identity, would go for it if we were isolated enough, they were just horny enough, or they were not getting any. I think TK has found this too. To be honest, the straighter, the more challenge, the better. Its part of some straight men fantasize about lesbians. Its not just a woman, its a woman that normally doesn't desire men, and has made a particular exception for just for you. Many gay men feel that about straight men. Out of all of the numerous attempts, only three times didn't work out and I only lost one friend (and that was on like the tenth try). I think the fact that I was dating and having sex with a bunch of woman at the time made it even easier because there was not the threat of me being a gay man factoring in on their decision.

    For a while I tried to maintain two separate relationships at once. One with a man and one with a woman. I was up front with both of them. Obviously, that could not sustain itself. After that point (1998) I always dated two people at once, I just realized they had to also be in the relationship. Some people would say that makes me a freak. I don't care.

    The real defining factor in me stopping to have sex with women was beginning to date matt who is much more strongly on the higher end of the Kinsey scale, as I think TK is.

    As with everything I tend to apply my personal experience to everyone else. Its weird in this case because I dont understand either side. I cannot understand how TK is sexually disgusted by woman, and I cannot understand how you are sexually unattracted to men. I can respect it, I just cannot understand. To TK I would say, we all came out of there and how can you not love breasts. To you I would say lets not pretend there isnt a penis in your hand everyday, lol.

    At the same time I understand how it feels to have everyone else determine what they think you are. I feel like now every just assumes i am Kinsey 6 because I have two male partners. The truth is I limit myself for other reasons. And the fact that people can limit themselves for reasons besides sexual identity is what makes people question other people's identity to begin with. Not that I am questioning you. Okay, okay, I would like to se eyou around one asian homo just to make sure, lol.
  18. flacidness ·

    I really like that Paul LOL. I have had sex with women a few times and still do not like it. I have given it the old college try for sure :) I believe i have posted about it. Once in 2007 and twice in 2009. oops!
  19. matthew ·

    Just for the record, @paul, I don't want you having sex with other men any more than I not wanting you to have sex with other women. So I don't see how I factor into your lack of vaginal sex. And, I personally think the Kinsey scale is utter bullshit. But please carry one, this is interesting.
  20. tinypliny ·

    Okay I had to take that test.. and apparently I am a 3.
  21. YesThatCasey ·

    Lauren, it looks like during my reading I may have started to overlap the two concepts. I think some of this was due to articles and treatise I was reading, as I was not familiar with either term beforehand. Considering the expansion of homonormativity, and the relative infancy of these terms, I wouldn’t be surprised if heteronormativity expanded. Then again, maybe there are other terms that more accurately reflect these concepts.

    I found Duggan’s treatise very interesting, but more specialized (and politicized) than that which was being used by many other articles and sites. The term was in use for several years before she became heavily associated with it. I love what she is trying to convey; I’m just not sure it encompassed everything the term was being used to address.

    Tiny, I definitely don’t care in the sense that I want peoples’ perception to match the reality exactly as it is. That’s not a reasonable expectation, I am aware. I guess my caring starts when misperception influences actions that potentially have a negative impact on the way people treat each other. I mean that in a general context, not just personal. For those reasons, I figured these concepts (which may not match exactly what I was initially thinking about) were healthy to think about.

    TK, I already made it clear this was not a public discussion between myself and anyone, and added the blurb at the start of the post to try and further highlight this.

    As for your comment, you definitely are not giving equal weight to all the things I have shared with you. First of all, I don’t do a great deal of complaining about being single. I occasionally mention it; it is on my mind. However, I have also very clearly stated why I am single. I’m a little annoyed that I have to put this out here right now, but I have said that being a 36 year old unemployed man without any clear direction in my life, lacking a car, and being tight on my wallet, doesn’t exactly make me a hot catch. My confidence is at an extremely low point, the lowest its ever been. I’m not really trying to find a woman right now.

    When I bring up that I’m single, I think it should be easy to understand why I don’t accompany it with these facts every single time. I try to joke around about it, and keep the mood happy. If you expect me to never mention it, that’s a pretty unfair expectation. I’ve never asked anyone to feel sorry for me, so don’t put that on me. That’s your belief.

    I also don’t go to bars to meet women; I go to bars to hang out with friends. I feel like you already know that I’m a shy person, and I don’t flirt. I’ve never started a relationship in a bar. Though, if I was going to, it probably would be in a gay bar/club. These are the places I get hit on by women the most (and I mean, by a lot). Last time at Cathode I had a woman aggressively hitting on me. The last time at Marcellas I was grinding on a girl (something I rarely do) who came up to me and left the place with digits from another girl. Of course, since I’m not really putting myself out there, this is all secondary to the company that is the reason I am there. That, and the better music.

    Back on topic, the notion of a “normal straight” is my point. This is a misplaced, even useless, concept. When it comes to sexuality, the only thing that really matters is who you are attracted to/sleep with. It has nothing to do with who you hang out with, what places you frequent, or any other detail really. Interpreting unrelated actions as a sign of sexuality when there is ample evidence and sincere statements to the contrary is not conducive to an informed opinion.

    Paul, you are dead-on with the free-time pressures. Rebecca is someone who I would be around much more, but she works two jobs, has a child to care for, and very little free time as a result. Michaelene is in a similar situation, as are many others. On top of the time, there is the fact that I don’t enjoy being around children all that much. Gay people tend to be free of these problems. Glad you brought this point up.

    I’m pretty much a fan of the idea that sexual orientation is an outdated tool, its usefulness lost by the energy we need to expend in defining it and it’s necessary incompleteness regardless. That said, while you may be ok with either gender, there are still people who are not. I imagine there must be some people you do not find attractive. I think that can be related to how some people are not attracted to particular genders; they just happen to be different factors.

    I understand the notion of extending personal traits to others. However, this is often what gets people into trouble when it is taken too far, particularly when evidence to the contrary is ignored. I suppose it doesn’t help when you experience people who say one thing and eventually do another. Unfortunately, I don’t know a way to really separate those two, other than trying to measure the sincerity and honesty behind actions and words. But, extrapolating experience from a small group and applying that to everyone is definitely not the answer. This can be related to a wide range of things; for example, religious people who believe that non-believers just haven’t heard the word of God, instead of respecting their differing views and the thought they have put into their worldview.

    I should be clear that it isn’t a problem to question someone. Inquiry is how we grow. I think the problem is when we ignore the response for selfish or irrational reasons. Assuming someone is insincere in their response can have a detrimental impact on your perception of them, sometimes before you realize that it’s happening. This can have a negative impact on how people interact, which I hope people can reduce by being conscious of these natural tendencies. It’s ok if we don’t understand something, but filling that lack of understanding with an unsupported belief is not ok.

    Oh, and kudos for working in an NWA reference…that was definitely unexpected. ;o)
  22. flacidness ·

    Casey I'm not doing this here.
  23. metalpeter ·

    Just have to ad my two Cents or maybe it is more like a Dollar...
    @e:tinypliny there is kinda a joke but the term trisexual means you will try anything once.....
  24. metalpeter ·

    Now the next thing I'm going to say or would that be write may get a few people upset with me but it is just my view from what I have seen growing up....

    Mexicans and Puerto Ricans don't get along, Island and City PR's donate get along, Jews think they are the only people ever oppressed, I have heard lesbians hate men, Blacks hate whites (cracker) and visa Versa, Africans Hate sons of slaves, Catholics hate baptists, Different kinds of Muslims kill each other in Iraq..... My point is that everyone even if they don't know it or even if it is a good one holds sterotypes... So if I was in a gay bar and someone thought I was gay and they didn't believe me when I said I wasn't there would be some reasons for them to think this just based on sterotypes.... But also from a logic perspective it would make more sense of "Oh he is just trying to turn me down" "he is gay but doesn't know it" "Oh he isn't out to everyone in the group" The lie from a logic perspective makes more sense.......



    I guess the thing at the End of the day is that we all look at our selves one way and people look at us a different way.... Now often to see who we are really and not whom we think we are we have to try and look at it from the other persons Perspective or one out side of our selves.... Don't have a real example other then when we think back on something from our past and go you know what I really was a Jerk but we couldn't think of it then.... Best example is when someone says I'm not like everyone else and they shave their head and get all these piercings and get a leather Jacket and they are like the only kid or only one of about 3 in there huge school who looks like that.... Then they go to a concert in town or even warped tour and there and hundreds of people dressed and looking just like that same sub culture..... Now in school they are the weirdo the out cast but at that show they part of a culture... Yes it has been called the hot topic culture .....

💬 Write a comment