01/23/12 10:19 - ID#55976
Beauty and Cheering
I feel pretty confident this guy will be doing great things, of which we will probably come across again.
On a slightly related albeit completely different topic of discussion, this is one of a continuing series of performances that make me want to shush the crowd.
In western culture, particularly American, there is an urge (possibly even a responsibility) to vocally express approval of a performance while it is ongoing. While the energy in some events, such as a football game, justifies this action, there are many others where it seems to obviously detract from the performance and yet we do so anyway.
This performance was a stark example. The music is very intimate, the motions gentle, and the crowd jarring in comparison.
This happens on a lot of things that I consume these days, though perhaps that's because I've been watching so much dancing material. But, even things like mix martial arts see very different crowd responses in some parts of the world. Specifically, in Japan, they treat MMA as we treat an opera, a hush over the entire crowd, with the silence being broken only on the most spectacular and unexpected occurrences. While I couldn't argue against others cheering in this case, I personally appreciate the silence far more; I feel it expresses a deeper respect for the contest taking place, and eliminates the feel of blood-lust in the crowd (and, indirectly, the community).
I'm curious how others feel about crowd cheers and jeers.
This is actually a topic that I considered writing about during this last break before I was sidetracked. At some point I'd like to research the origins and growth of this phenomenon.
Permalink: Beauty_and_Cheering.html
Words: 299
Last Modified: 01/23/12 10:19
01/12/12 07:30 - ID#55894
Hetero/homonormativity
These two terms are still in the growing stages and, as a result, seem to vary in what I’ve read. I’ll provide a short (and perhaps poor) summary on the part that is currently important to me:
Homonormativity asserts that everybody with any lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender (homosexual) connection is and acts as if they were homosexual.
Heteronormativity asserts that heterosexuals fall within traditional gender roles and attitudes.
More reading, if so inclined:
Homonormativity
Heteronormativity
At this point in my life I am surrounded by gay friends. I have 2 circles of largely gay friends, and another circle of every-type-of-bisexuality friends. I don’t really have any strictly straight circles that I’m around with any regularity. My two closest friends are gay.
This isn’t something that I think about much. It doesn’t matter to me. I don’t hang out with people because of their sexuality; I hang out with them because I think they are good people and I enjoy their company, and hopefully that feeling is reciprocal.
But, occasionally, and especially recently, I find that my sexuality is being questioned.
I am straight. But, since I am often in gay bars with my gay friends, and not ‘acting’ as straight as most other straight people, and not walking around with a girl on my arm, the notion that I can be straight seems to be difficult to grasp.
This is nowhere near the first time I have faced this attitude. I generally take it as a compliment; I hear ‘you are an individual’. That’s cool with me. I have fun joking around with it; pushing the line where I can for entertainment’s sake.
It’s more difficult to do that when a person’s attitude towards you changes just because you aren’t what they think you should be.
I don’t care that my personality doesn’t match what people think it should for a straight person. I’m damn well not going to act differently just because someone thinks I need to in order to prove who I am. It pisses me off that a person who belongs to a group that is still frequently persecuted, and who I have fought for regardless of the fact that I myself am not directly included in that group, is then going to turn around and give me attitude because I don’t fit in a particular mold. Insinuating that I’m not being honest, either with others or myself, is really insulting.
How is it that humans so consistently, and quickly, lose sight of the place we just left?
Permalink: Hetero_homonormativity.html
Words: 470
Last Modified: 01/13/12 01:35
01/10/12 04:37 - ID#55883
Georgia's Anti-obesity Campaign
YouTube collection of the videos uploaded by the campaign:
I do find myself concerned about how this could negatively affect an obese child's self-perception. I also worry about the potential of increased bullying.
That said, I know that these children will face serious health issues. I know there is a lack of honest dialogue with the parents, and between the parents and their children, regarding the obesity that each child is facing. I know that there is a complacency surrounding this matter that is curtailing the potential for corrective actions. I know that, having conditioned their body to live this way, and not knowing any other way of life, it will be increasingly difficult to correct this problem as they enter adulthood, and by the time they reach that point there will be some damage that cannot be undone.
Since the campaign seems to have been successful in bringing the conversation out into the open, I find myself supporting the campaign. I certainly would not have followed the same approach were I leading the campaign. I would have portrayed the children as empowered, challenging their parents notions about what is good for them, rallying against fast/unhealthy foods, and demanding better school lunches. But, with how many children are facing this matter, I find myself reluctant to shun an effort that I believe will have a net-positive result.
The organizers have said that this is the first of a 3-part campaign. Further spots will be more positive, with a focus on the actions necessary to combat the issue. It will be interesting to see what they cover. I hope that they are effective, and less controversial, as I believe this is a PSA we need in all states, not just Georgia.
Permalink: Georgia_s_Anti_obesity_Campaign.html
Words: 315
Last Modified: 01/10/12 04:41
Author Info
YesThatCasey
Date Cloud
Category Cloud
- User must have at least 3 blogs in one category for categories list to show.
On the other hand, I might not have noticed. I think I fall clearly into the selfish bin based on your classification. And I don't know if I can change it. I have walked out in the middle of plays/shows/films because I didn't support the concept anymore or been completely revolted/bored or both, cheered entirely too much, hooted at the stage, whooped and headbanged, got into fights (that was in my metal stage), thrown confetti, danced like a loon. You name an atrocious audience act and I have done it. ;-)
As you touched on, the will of the crowd will change depending on culture, the quality of the performance, and the individuals personality. What I'm suggesting is that currently, in our culture, there seems to be an excessive pressure to cheer performances. That implies that there are plenty of times where cheering is not only acceptable, but appropriate, and possibly unavoidable. I don't want to suggest that any of that needs to change.
What does bother me is when these responses occur without consideration of whole picture. When people feel that by not cheering or laughing they are somehow letting down the entertainers. Similarly, I don't want performers to think that the silence of the crowd means they are not entertaining them. Neither one of these needs to be true; we are forcing these beliefs onto people.
A comedy show is a clear example of an event where the audience will always respond vocally, and where silence could be construed as failure. That is quite different from the performance above. I equate what happened there with sitting on an isolated beach, sharing a tender moment with a girl, and having some guy rush up and shout "WHOOOP!" out of nowhere. Not only is it completely out of place, but it takes away from the emotion you are experiencing.
This performance brings out at least two things: amazing physical prowess, and a tender expression of emotion. The cheers ignore and ruin half of the performance as far as I'm concerned.
I often went to heavy metal concerts back home. I think crowd participation plays an big role in those concerts. Whole sections of audience often sing missing lines and phrases and there is this whole call-and-answer-with-chorus section to many songs.
I admit I feel somewhat out of place when the audience is too quiet. I love it when the whole theatre claps, chants etc during random movies and plays. The last time I was at a movie (bad choice, btw) many women were crying. I reached over and patted the hand of one woman who was really losing it. It was the highlight of that whole movie-going experience for me. Some shows like Fuerza Bruta rely on how the audience responds.
Isn't fighting all about competition and insanity of it all? I would totally shout my lungs out if I were into some fight! :) (which I am not, but just sayin...)
so I think it not only depends on the culture, it depends on how you feel about the performance, what kind of a person you are and in general, whether you care two hoots about who else is watching any show with you (I could not care less). I once gave a long and crazy standing ovation at a classical piano concert when there was no one else even willing to stand. After the show, at the reception, the pianist came and thanked me for clapping so hard. It was funny, and no I didn't know the pianist before the show.
But there is another part of me that thinks but no cause we shut up for some sports like Tennis and Golf and maybe Gymnastics...... So maybe it is a tradition thing?
Just tossing a few idea out there.... I think that as Americans we are taught you like something clap.... Look at sports like Monster trucks and Freestyle Motocross you are supposed to get loud (like they can really hear you over the engines well maybe they can) as they do it so they do bigger and better tricks so they get pumped.... This will sometimes lead the everyone cheering at a show when the song starts or intro ends or at the end of the song but not when it is 100% over?
So maybe this way we are taught carry over into areas where it shouldn't ?
Again not only in Pro Wrestling, But with all kinds of live concerts now, and even (I don't mean heckling )Like improve comedy their is crowd participation and so that has to be at least a part of the factor...
Of course I have no way to figure out what causes what.... But being at home watching sports and yelling at the TV or watching you tube may factor in as well?
I have never seen the Japanese MMA but what I have watched is Japanese Wrestling Now mind you in was some years ago back when ECW was around ok maybe a year past that.... Now culture does change over time.... But it was the same way big move over big move and no sound I was like what... End of the match clapping or in a death match on nails nothing , barbed wire boards nothing, only a cheer like you said when something huge happened like the guy was thrown into the corner into the lights that are lite and they explode......
I think performance arts such as this one.. or things like CIrque de Soleil feed on audience enthusiasm and cheers, however loud they may be. What if the sound track was a slightly heavier cello track or maybe a Hendrix solo? Maybe the more classical bent of the music made the crowd response seem jarring,