data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/766ae/766ae327ad45a9b2b59ef5ccd99d8f6fbabb5b72" alt=""
Based on federal data from calendar year 2007, per 100,000 residents:
Buffalo, NY - Population 273,832 (66th among large US cities)
Violent Crime - 15th (comparable to DC - Chicago didn't report data on violent crime!)
Property Crime - 20th (comparable city of disrepute - Oakland, CA)
Murder/Negligent Manslaughter - 10th (higher than Miami, Chicago, Memphis)
Forcible Rape - 17th
Robbery - 15th (in between Dallas and Chicago)
20th - Aggravated Assault (higher than Chicago, DC)
14th - Burglary
11th - Larceny-theft
32nd - Motor Vehicle Theft (more profitable in better weather)
26th - Arson
Buffalo outranked Boston, Newark, NYC, Chicago, Houston and Los Angeles in every crime category except for the following: Boston (aggravated assault, 13th), Newark (murder and auto theft, both 4th), Houston (auto theft 24th, arson 21st).
That's right - Newark, NJ - regularly considered the armpit of the east and one of the most latently dangerous cities in America, is reported to have 30% less violent crime, 60% less rapes, 25% less robberies, 30% less aggravated assaults, 30% less property crime, almost 3x less burglaries and half the larceny than what we have in Buffalo. Don't worry though - you are "only" twice as likely to get murdered in Newark, and are twice as likely to have your ride "borrowed" for a while. So, in my final estimation, either Buffalo is significantly more dangerous than Newark, NJ and the biggest cities in America (per 100,000) or the stats volunteered by the cities are downplayed to a criminal degree.
Don't forget - as a policy our city doesn't inform its citizens on a regular basis when crimes occur in your area unless they feel like it. And by your area I mean down the block. Cheers! *clink* (and no, the clink might not have been your window being cut by a glass cutter)
Remember all this the next time the city spends your tax dollars on stuff like $50,000 cameras, which have yielded no tangible improvement on your safety, but make you "feel better" depending on the neighborhood you are in. And I'll be the last guy to complain about pay for cops, but in the past year we've had a cop "allegedly" try to defraud our car insurer, and looking at the crime statistics you are DAMN RIGHT that they should be held to scrutiny. If you want to cry about what you're being paid, then you are god damn right that I want to see what it is that you're doing to justify those tears.
Here is the question - based on the crime stats (and stats aren't everything until its you that gets hurt) is the tax money you are shelling out for often grandiose police salaries and benefits worth what it is that you are getting back in terms of public safety? The answer is no. In the end is all proportional but when New York and LA's proportional crime rate is lower than yours in Buffalo, something is wrong and it isn't the way the stats are being tabulated.
I would have never thought that. People in my neighborhood refer to Newark as "the war zone" and a general rule of thumb is don't go there unless necessary.
I believe police should be well paid. I don't know what Buffalo cops make though, to I can't comment on it.
That being said, I think that our tax dollars are better spent preventing crime in ways other than police/cameras--things like smart planning (thanks (e:james)).
I've read the stats. I've heard the stories, but I still feel safe. I guess I'm naive.
I checked it out a little - there's no one easy-to-access, up-to-date source for that data.
Here's some 2000 data that allows you to search by state & agency with >100 sworn officers:
:::link:::
Buffalo has 32 sworn officers per 10,000
Rochester ditto
Syracuse 33
Newark, NJ 54
DC 63
Here's an old report on the # of cops per 10,000 in the 25 largest cities:
:::link::: (1996 data)
Crime is indelibly linked to poverty. Shitty ass city planning has left half the city a sprawling slum and is where, I am willing to bet, the lion's share of crimes are committed. But, UB is in Amherst, we can't get a fucking box store to move in downtown after ten years of negotiations, and highways segregate the safe white neighborhoods from the bad black neighborhoods.
We shit on our dinner plate and they cringe when we have to eat it.
lol @ Ajay... too true. I haven't been to the MojaveExperiment site yet, although by my own admission I don't know if/when I'd ever switch personally. I'm most inclined to get a Mac next, but even then I know I'd want Windoze/Mac OS dual boot. I think I've been conditioned, possibly.
(e:heidi) - I wish I knew that. It would be most relevant.
I call shenanigans!
Redmond, WA is listed near the bottom; that can't be right! It's the headquarters of the world's biggest criminal empire.
Plus, every time you buy a Windows box, you get raped.
Just curious - are there stats about # of police officers per 100,000 residents?