
Coffee shop owner convicted of arson
By Matt Gryta
NEWS STAFF REPORTER
July 28, 2009, 7:02 AM / 3 comments
Buffalo coffee shop owner Lon Coldiron was convicted Monday night of third-degree arson and second-degree attempted grand larceny in the October 2004 fire that destroyed his business and killed one of his three pet dogs.
The jury found Coldiron, 43, not guilty of attempted third-degree grand larceny. Erie County Judge Thomas P. Franczyk set bail at $50,000 and scheduled sentencing for Sept. 4.
Coldiron, 43, did not testify or present any alibi witnesses during the two-week trial, his second in connection with the fire that destroyed Coffee &, his shop at 718 Elmwood Ave.
Three years ago, Coldiron was convicted only of attempted grand larceny and placed on probation. He was granted a new trial 12 months ago by the Appellate Division of State Supreme Court because of jury misconduct during deliberations before then-County Judge Timothy J. Drury.
The appellate court stressed that while it found "legally sufficient" evidence to support the arson and attempted insurance fraud charges, a new trial was warranted because of misconduct by unidentified jurors who sneaked legal documents into the deliberation room.
"The jury's possession of that written material" warranted a trial reversal, the Rochester court ruled, upholding arguments by Buffalo Legal Aid Bureau appeals attorney Nicholas T. Texido.
Prosecutors Mark A. Sacha and Amy B. Benedict proved Coldiron had applied for about $290,000 in business insurance on the shop about a month before the fire and that he had been awaiting an insurance company inspection of his business at the time of the arson.
The prosecutors also cited evidence of Coldiron had gambling casino debts at the time.
John K. Jordan, Coldiron's attorney, contended his client, who lived in a third-floor flat above the shop and had to leap to the roof of an adjoining business to escape the flames, had "cooperated fully with the investigation" of the arson.
Days after the fire, neighbors staged a benefit for Coldiron.
mgryta@buffnews.com
I remember walking in and asking them if they wanted to put up a free WiFi spot in there, for the cost of $45/mo. Didn't get an answer....
I just read your earlier post to place this in context. What an awful person! He deserves a nice spot in prison.
Didn't a pet die in the fire too? Or am I not remembering correctly? Either way, I'm glad this goon was brought to justice.
Ah yes, the coffee shop where I met Libertad before all other estrippers.
Glad he got what was coming.
This was a disgrace. I honestly do miss that coffee shop... I was a regular there until it burned down. Too bad it was owned by a psychopath.