The place is on the corner of Auburn and West, deep on the west side. This is what you're looking for:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9d1dc/9d1dc4396386dc618af9a4a797f0a592ea28b144" alt="image"
This is facing the West St. side. West is a southbound one way street - you can take Lafayette and go down that way to Auburn, or do what I did, which was to take Auburn and drive the wrong way 20 ft (purely accidental, I assure you) and park in the first available spot near the corner.
This is how it works - basically, when you walk in you'll have some steel grate between you and the cashier, on the right. You pick up your food, and the food is then slotted through a locked Plexiglas window to you. I could see some white bread types being intimidated by this process - if that is you, order delivery because the west side will probably freak you out to begin with. What you'll miss, however, is some really friendly people. The guy in there was great and I'll be back in person many times.
The food: we ordered a lot because we wanted to give people a reasonable sample of the menu. We ordered two entrees and two sides, which quickly grew to include two desserts. I never order desserts when I eat outside of home, but I had to try the flan. They insisted I try the bread pudding as well and hooked me up with that.
For starters, the rolled tacos with salsa, guacamole and sour cream ($2.25).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7af5f/7af5fab6b486629ca97c934ae9e138c7f4cde843" alt="image"
Hot, crispy, awesome. These are stuffed with beef - they had beef and pizza to choose from... we had the beef. The salsa and guac - oh my god, fantastic. I have to say, this is a nice little side.
Next - a beef pastelillo ($1.75).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/db773/db7735f6b4359ff8cade10d74dd172997dc8195e" alt="image"
Typical - these are on hand and warm when you arrive. It is what it is - quick and cheap fried pocket filled with beef. Not bad, not spectacular.
Next - my entree. Pernil (roast pork) with red beans and rice and fried plantains ($7.95).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/62e52/62e528895a8854fec5a1d89f4e2e435961a6f340" alt="image"
I love roast pork - this was succulent without being fatty, had the qualities of roast pork that I enjoy (different textures that ultimately affect the flavor). The plantains came with a dipping sauce which I can't describe perfectly, other than to say it is very much like a remoulade. I love beans like this - as it should be, swimming in the sauce with onions, spices, etc.
Jay's meal - pollo asado (roast chicken) with the same sides I had ($7.95).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e662a/e662ab07d2152f95f771abe0b0d69225c06cefc7" alt="image"
A quarter of roast chicken with red beans and rice and fried plantains. Jason struggles with sauces and dressings so he ate the plantains as they were. He loved everything else - in my opinion (and perhaps Jason agrees with me) roasting is the second most perfect method of cooking, behind barbecue.
Desserts - I got talked into it, but I haven't had flan since I was in DR ($2.15).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6de79/6de7984ea3aac0517f978fdc4c664e2dff7bfcdb" alt="image"
The custard was as it should be - perfect texture. Loved the flavor. My only nitpick was that I wish the caramel sauce was a little thicker and richer.
And finally - the bread pudding ($1.75).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/53c55/53c550d08d3f4c681d9b6a830d94694a1c5b3e33" alt="image"
I might like this better than the flan - definite deeper caramel flavor, with a little denser texture. Caramel and raisin goodness - a nice surprise. Thanks Carmen's!
For me, definitely worth a second visit. They have other items on the menu that are traditional and interesting, including sandwiches (roast pork sandwich!), stews, a couple things I haven't heard of before. The Mexican side of the menu will be familiar to many - I wanted to concentrate more on the Puerto Rican side of things. What I'm most curious about on the Mexican side are the tacos and the burritos.
We order from there for International Fest (at Canisius) every year!
Awesome review! Thanks!
I'll be curious to hear your opinions, guys.
I liked it - a former co-worker of mine is Puerto Rican and for her the roast pork was major comfort food, grandma-style, so I had to try it.
I just pinched a piece of leftovers that has been in the fridge for 4 hours or so - still pretty tender. This pork was much better than the roast rack of lamb I had at Lario's in Miami, which was a lot more expensive. I'll be curious to see what you think of it - I hope you enjoy it too. My only possible point of criticism is that for some it may be the slightest shade too salty, but personally it wasn't much of a surprise.
By the way I didn't notice any oil issues with the food, really - the fried plantains weren't overly greasy. (Obvious issue with the pastelillo). Loved the tacos w/the salsa - guac is extra but good.
I have passed this and wondered how it was. I can't wait to try it.
Good to know the pork was good. From what little i know of Puerto Rican food, it is all about the pork. And if, by god, you say that pork was good then I am going.