We got charged a lot of money for the plumber to put two holes in our wall. Whatever homeowner put the plumbing in must have been awfully optimistic that there would never be a plumbing problem, because they didn't put in an access door to the plumbing. I guess they won, because we're the ones stuck with the problem.
Apparently, putting holes in the wall was a hit or miss kind of thing because here's hole #1 leading to nothing:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/19ef8/19ef877e3b8bcaa83af0d2aa3601e884ad53a940" alt="image"
And here's hole #2 which led to what he needed:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3e3e8/3e3e8034b2c2285e915dd7701d54676495c2e442" alt="image"
And here's the two fixtures that he replaced in the bathtub I now need to clean:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3dc73/3dc73566f1171d9a481f180b30a265c7aa6a3039" alt="image"
Apparently the large sum he charged us didn't include putting a door on or replacing the plaster or tidying up a bit in the bathroom. So, we'll be doing those fun little projects ourselves.
Definitely use the pix you took to go with your other stuff if you challenge your assessment - bathrooms are expensive.
I really don't understand of how it can be hit or miss. Is it not measurable where the bathtub is? Its not like the bathtub pipes could be anywhere but behind the bathtub.
To be fair, what he quoted us is the same as someone else quoted us. So it's the going rate it seems. And I suppose he's a plumber not a contractor. It just didn't occur to me that we would have to repair the wall.
Why don't you say their name. SOunds crappy.
If you assess your home the way the city of Buffalo does that should drop your value by at least 20k