So here I am with this person and in my best interest I've basically handled this with kid gloves, since I don't want this to become a grease fire & shitting in my nest is something that is not on my list of things to experience in life.
So here's my problem: She's pretty attractive and very moral in the sense that she's a church girl and even does music for various Catholic Churches. But as I've eluded to in

Just like the Angel on one shoulder and the Devil on the other duking it out I have this dilemma on my hands. I think my mind has been tainted in the "Tainted Love" sense by the alternagoth queens that I've always ended up with in the past that produced great longing and sex. Then again I've always have been battling this dark feeling of helplessness every time I come across some obstacle that most people can just get over but to me and my perception always seems monolithic. Nothing will scare a normal chick away like that kind weak, helpless whining. I've always felt this way, but luckily it only comes cyclically. Or at least less frequently due to me playing a big game of avoiding making large decisions in life to snuff out an possibility of me mourning a shitty decision and taking a trip down a spiral for weeks or a couple months at a time due to that one thing.
So anyway I have this chick that's into me and is pretty nice and wholesome. The last thing I want to do is fuck with her head as I have with so many people [Although for most of those participants, it was mutual] But at the same time the inner Catholic altar boy wants a nice wholesome no psycho wife that will be all quaint and "normal" whatever that means anymore or in actuality some concept of "normal" from the unobtainable permanently lost past.
There's just a battle in me that has been going on for years. The "normal" person that can hang with frat boys versus the dark existentialist that loves indie films and depressed artistic sex fiends with multicolored yarn hair that listen to stuff that makes NIN sound mild. The excuse of blaming my high school just isn't cutting it anymore. Do I have to make a decision or marry someone that will force me to live a secret double life?
Yea, I have issues I know...
I agree with the others, also, especially (e:ladycroft). You just don't know what she's like until you spend time together alone. Communication and honesty are going to get you a lot farther in finding a woman than worrying quietly. If you're communicating and honest, then you're not going to be fucking with her head, you'll both know what's going on and can make appropriate choices.
I'm with the other comments.
Take time to get to know her- if you want to find out if she is wife material for you, then you have to really open up communication. She may be shy and holding back too, but underneath she might be looking for someone who she can safely get freaky with, explore all the cool dirty things that are sometimes most amazing between a true long term relationship/friendship than a casual thing. Outward appearances dont tell as much as the story as we are led to believe. Maybe she's wholesome on the outside (like you), and all things open territory behind closed doors (like you).
I too am rooting for you!
Oh, I love when things fall into your lap. But, then again, the last time that happened to me I got a glorified drinking buddy. That didn't do mmhmmhmm. Sometimes mate, you do want to choose.
And, you're totally right about the weak, helpless whining. People like being with people who can see the bright side of life and roll with the punches.
It doesn't matter who you are with, some of the time she is going to bring the psycho. The question is whether or not the nature and degree of the psycho is something you can handle. A lit match is a hell of a lot better than napalm.
But all of this thinking kills me because instead of thinking too much, why not just enjoy what you have? You've got to slow down and smell the fucking roses. You've got to concentrate on having fun with her instead. Make things easier on yourself and take the pressure off.
Has the subject of marriage actually come up? At first I thought it sounded like you were just kind of hanging out and casually dating. If what you want is a 'wholesome' wife, the goth queen probably isn't going to work out so well. But...are you making assumptions about just how 'wholesome' she is? Who says she wouldn't dress up for you now and then to appease your burning desire for the dark side? Sometimes we think we desire something because it's all we've known, or find it 'comfortable'. Your inner peace is worth more so don't be tricked by the devil on your shoulder. Bottom line though, is have this discussion with HER. The more communication you open up the better! I'm rooting for you!