Have you ever wondered why..,
- Your comment # is more than the total number of comments on the home page?
- Some comments you make mysteriously vanish into the night?

- Some comments get lost and never see the light of the day?
- As you look down the new comment column, the ghost of your comment still taunts you from the netherworld??
- Is there a secret comment graveyard on (e:strip)?

- Is that where unruly comments go to die?
The answer lies with...
(e:paul)!!!!!!!*
PS: (e:paul) just posted in the chatter: tiny when you are posting a comment, make sure it says the right user and comment id at the top of the add comment window e.g. Post a comment to imk2's journal #46680
PPS: Thanks for that information. I will be sure to check in the future but how about the comments which have been posted without verifying this detail - is there any way to recover them?
PPPS: I am so addicted to this font-sizing thing. :)
My previous problems with it occurred when I would start the comment, then move over to another Firefox tab and then submit the comment.
Paul, thanks for the tool. I've been meaning to read something (e:DCoffee) had posted a while back.
The test is working now. :) It's the murphy's law. I will keep a hawk's eyeout for the next time I get signs of a lost comment. The comment that got lost today was the first one I made after being inactive for around 7 hours.
Test it and see what happens.
If I think back to my comments in the graveyard, I think they do have a definite pattern. (E:strip) reuses pop-up windows. If you click on the comment bubble to comment on someone's blog, the earlier pop-up from (e:strip) is replaced by the comment form pop-up. I am guessing lost comments mostly happen when you have a log-out event between 2 pop-up sessions. When you login again and initiate a pop-up from (e:strip), the replacement pop-up comment goes to the graveyard.
THAT IS SO COOL!!! THANK YOU!!
Now we can all go rescue out lost and bewildered comments!!! GO COMMENT RESCUE!!! Dig them out of those coffins!!!
Okay, its there is a comment graveyard now :::link::: where you can get to the list of all 40/40,000 comments with no home
You can also get there by clicking on the graveyard link on the more comments page. They are in reverse chronological order. If you know which ones they belong on, click the report link at the bottom of any comment.
Also, in the more list itself, it a comment is ever not associated with a journal, there is a "report this" link instead of a >>more link so that you can easily report it.
Yes, they are all alive and well. I am just holding them hostage No the truth is there are ~40 out of 40,333 comments that have no journal associated with them. They are still in the database. I have the author, the comments, the timestamp and the ip but somehow those ones never passed the journal id. I cannot figure out the exact combination of problem that causes it. Everytime I try it it works.
That is why I added that line at the top that says what journal id and user you are posting to. If that ever says nothing, that is an indicator that there is a problem and I would really like to know under what condition that happens.
I should just make a lost comment graveyard where you can go to claim them. This problem won't happen in the new system as it works very differently. Unfortunately, I have been very busy with work and other things and it keeps delaying the new version. If only this was my paid job.