I will admit, Emma is probably one of my least favourite works by Austen, but this 2009 adaptation does as much justice to the novel as the 1995 version of Pride and Prejudice. In fact, it makes it so picturesque that I am almost ready to overlook the fact that I am always uncomfortable with Emma's character in the real book.
Romola Garai is SO not the Emma that Austen wrote about. She has absolutely no pretension, is much too earnest and can't pull off the insularity that is the trademark of Austen's Emma! For a change, I loved the fact that they miscast so far from the truth that I actually liked this Emma.
Oh, the soundtrack is GORGEOUS and I have been listening to it non-stop for days on end!! It has a bunch of lively innovative waltzes
and some heart-breaking cello and flute pieces
and really everything in-between.

(e:Jacob), you MUST see this (especially if you don't like the real Emma too much. heheh)
Haha that is so funny! I don't know why I assumed you must have read Emma. Believe it not, I read one or two novels by Austen, went through the complete George Eliot, Agatha Christie, some Somerset Maugham, the entire Saki, P G Wodehouse, Austin Freeman, Ngaio Marsh and whatnot before I returned to Austen because I had nothing else to read at that time! Austen was BORING compared to the others! :)
So, I have a confession: I've never read Emma. (-_-*) I know, I'm not a true connoisseur. So let me get back to you on the comparison of book and movie. Of course, I'll enjoy the music regardless. (But, I do love the dance.)